Phillies Plan to Reduce J.T. Realmuto’s Catching Workload in 2027

| 5 min read

J.T. Realmuto’s durability has given the Phillies an unusual amount of stability at catcher. Now, with a difficult season at the plate behind him and his 36th birthday approaching, Philadelphia plans to give him fewer starts behind the plate in 2027. The change looks like workload management aimed at keeping him fresh, not a verdict on his defense. Catcher is physically demanding, and reducing time there can also create opportunities to rest a veteran’s legs without removing his bat from the lineup.

Realmuto has started 613 games at catcher since 2022, the most in the majors. His 122 starts this season edged Milwaukee’s William Contreras by one. At the Phillies’ year-end press conference Thursday, president of baseball operations Dave Dombrowski said he had already raised the prospect of scaling that back.

“I said, ‘I don’t know if I can accomplish this, but I don’t want you to hear about it from the press conference,’” Dombrowski said of speaking with Realmuto. “‘My goal is to try to reduce the number of games you catch.’” He said Realmuto feels fine physically and is open to more days away from the position, potentially taking on additional time at first base. That openness gives the club room to manage his workload while keeping him involved in the offense, though it still has to decide who handles the innings behind the plate.

A difficult first season of a new deal

The workload conversation follows a disappointing 2026 campaign. Realmuto signed a three-year, $45 million contract with Philadelphia in January, then posted a .205/.283/.331 line with 11 home runs across 467 plate appearances. His 68 wRC+ was the lowest of his career and well below the 91 mark for major-league catchers this season. For a player whose value has long rested partly on contributing regularly at a demanding position, that gap makes the club’s plan a question of both health and production.

His strikeout rate improved to 21.4% and his walk rate to 7.9%, both better than in 2025. Those gains suggest that some parts of his approach moved in the right direction, but they didn’t translate into strong results. The results were still poor in nearly every month; July, when he recorded a 130 wRC+, was the exception. One productive month offers a sign of what he can still do, but it doesn’t establish that the broader decline has passed.

Some of the decline may reflect bad fortune on balls in play. Realmuto’s .239 BABIP was far below his previous career low of .285, and his actual average and slugging percentage trailed his expected marks of .249 and .387. Those expected figures also sat below his career norms. His contact quality weakened, too: his hard-hit rate dropped from 45.4% to 40.0%, just below average, while his barrel rate fell by 3.2 percentage points. The numbers point in two directions at once: poor luck may have made his line look worse, but weaker contact gives little reason to treat the season as a simple statistical fluke.

Finding enough rest behind the plate

Realmuto remains effective in several important defensive areas. Defensive Runs Saved rated him at -5, while Fielding Run Value placed him at 0, so the measures don’t deliver a clear case that his overall defense has become a liability. Statcast ranked his pop time in the 98th percentile, and he continued to excel at throwing out would-be base stealers. Blocking was a weaker part of his game, but he went 70 for 86 on challenges through the ABS system, an 81.4% success rate. That mix helps explain why fewer starts can be framed as preservation: the club can recognize the strain of the position without concluding that Realmuto can no longer play it well.

The more immediate roster question is who can absorb the extra catching starts. The Phillies’ other catchers on the 40-man roster are Rafael Marchán and Garrett Stubbs. Marchán has 334 career plate appearances since 2020 and a 58 wRC+; Stubbs has a 47 wRC+ since 2023. Both offer defensive value, but their offensive records leave little room to assume either can handle a substantially larger role. A backup doesn’t need to match Realmuto’s production, yet the gap matters if additional starts turn into a regular share of the schedule.

Payroll adds another constraint

Philadelphia could look outside the organization for a backup, though its projected payroll is already high. MLBTR’s Payroll Tracker puts the club’s 2027 cash payroll at $262.8 million before its projected $36 million arbitration class, estimated by MLBTR contributor Matt Swartz. Non-tenders could trim that figure, and backup catchers generally don’t require a major free-agent commitment. Even so, the Phillies are likely to finish above their $291.8 million cash payroll from 2026. The room to add help depends on the club’s wider roster decisions, not simply on the cost of a reserve catcher.

The value of a second catcher

Philadelphia’s challenge is to create enough rest for Realmuto without exposing the lineup to a steep drop-off at catcher. This is more significant than it looks: a plan to reduce one player’s workload only works if the replacement innings are dependable enough for the club to stick with it. A shallow offensive alternative could make those rest days costly, while asking Realmuto to keep catching at his recent pace would undercut the stated goal.

If you’re working in this space, the useful question is how the Phillies balance those costs across the season. A capable complement could let Realmuto spend more time at first base and give the club flexibility when his bat needs a break. And yet. The available options’ records make that outcome uncertain, and a change in position won’t by itself repair his contact quality.

The available evidence points to a deliberate reduction in his starts; how much that helps his bat will depend partly on whether the Phillies can find a more dependable complement. The plan has a clear rationale, but its success rests on a roster choice the club hasn’t resolved. In practical terms, the catcher’s workload and the backup’s ability are now tied together. (And this is the part most people overlook.)

Photo courtesy of Kyle Ross, Imagn Images

Source: AJ Eustace · www.mlbtraderumors.com