Yankees Face Costly Decision at Third Base After Ryan McMahon’s Down Year

| 5 min read

The Yankees’ third-base problem is a roster and payroll question wrapped together. Ryan McMahon’s bat fell well below average in 2026, and his once reliable defense slipped toward league average. He’s owed $16MM, while New York has several other expensive needs to address. Keeping him could preserve flexibility elsewhere; replacing him could help repair a lineup that struggled when Aaron Judge was hurt.

McMahon’s value took a sharp turn

McMahon appeared in 124 games and hit .213/.279/.357, producing a 78 wRC+—22% below the league average. His strikeout rate reached 29.4%, placing him in Statcast’s ninth percentile and landing close to his 29.3% career mark. The more notable change came in his ability to reach base and hit for power: his walk rate sank to a career-low 7.8%, and his .279 on-base percentage left little room for the power he once supplied.

After hitting at least 20 home runs in six of the previous seven seasons, McMahon finished 2026 with 11. His .143 isolated power was below the .156 league average and the lowest of his career. That combination made him a particularly weak fit for a contender seeking dependable production from a premium infield position.

The team’s results at third base underline the problem. Yankees third basemen posted a 74 wRC+, tied with Miami for the fifth-lowest mark in the majors. McMahon had averaged 2.3 fWAR per season from 2021 through 2025, with his defense helping support that value. This year, he managed just 0.5 fWAR, approximately replacement level.

His defensive numbers also moved in the wrong direction. McMahon had recorded +10 Defensive Runs Saved and +7 Outs Above Average at third base in 2025. In 2026, those figures fell to -3 DRS and 0 OAA. Statcast has generally credited him for his ability to range laterally, but that strength looked much closer to average this season.

Durability helps, but doesn’t explain the decline

McMahon’s durability had been one of his steadier contributions. He played at least 151 games in every season from 2021 to 2025, then missed time in 2026 with a throat infection in late June and a left thumb sprain in late August. Those were his first injured-list stints in more than seven years.

Neither injury offers an obvious explanation for diminished range at third base. A single-season downturn could prove temporary, but McMahon turns 31, and the Yankees have to consider whether this is the beginning of an age-related decline. His contract makes that uncertainty harder to ignore: $16MM is a meaningful commitment for a player whose offense has rarely been a strength and whose glove no longer looks like a reliable source of surplus value.

That doesn’t make a release an easy call. New York has other holes, and paying McMahon to play elsewhere would add dead money before the team has secured a replacement. The Yankees may decide they can tolerate his limitations for another season while directing resources toward more pressing needs.

New York’s other commitments narrow its options

The bullpen could absorb a substantial share of the offseason budget. Fernando Cruz is a non-tender candidate after an injury, while Paul Blackburn and closer David Bednar are entering free agency. Current reporting expects the Yankees to make Bednar a qualifying offer. If he accepts, his salary would rise; if he declines, retaining him could require a lucrative multiyear deal. New York may need additional relievers either way.

Second base could become another expense. Jazz Chisholm Jr. is a free agent, though he has said he wants to remain in New York. The Yankees have considered Luis Garcia Jr. at the position. If Garcia instead stays at first base, Anthony Volpe could be the next internal option, despite his own offensive shortcomings.

Giancarlo Stanton’s place on the roster adds another layer. The 36-year-old, who turns 37 in November, is entering the final season of the 13-year, $325MM extension he signed with Miami in November 2014. He is due a $25MM salary in 2027 and has a $10MM buyout attached to a club option for 2028. The Marlins are responsible for $20MM, leaving the Yankees with a $15MM guarantee.

Stanton had another injury-interrupted season, and both Ben Rice and Judge could see time at designated hitter. New York could decide to release Stanton and absorb the remaining cost, but doing so would further complicate an already crowded payroll calculation.

MLBTR’s Payroll Tracker places the Yankees at $282.1MM in luxury-tax payroll for 2027 before arbitration raises. Matt Swartz projects the team’s arbitration-eligible players to earn $36.7MM. New York is therefore likely to approach the highest luxury-tax threshold. If collective bargaining negotiations produce a salary cap, the club could face pressure to reduce payroll instead. In either case, paying McMahon or Stanton not to play would make the search for replacements more difficult.

The replacement market offers no easy answer

The free-agent market includes Teruaki Sato, one of the most prominent bats available at any position. That profile is likely to draw multiple suitors and a substantial price. Other possibilities bring their own questions: Alec Bohm would be a rebound bet, while Chisholm and J.P. Crawford would be shifting to a position that isn’t their usual home.

Trades could offer a different route. Isaac Paredes of the Astros, Royce Lewis of the Twins and Nolan Gorman of the Cardinals are among the potential targets. Houston holds a $13.35MM club option on Paredes, which would become a mutual option if he finishes in the top 10 of American League MVP voting. He is otherwise in his final year of team control, giving the Astros a possible reason to trade him and redirect the savings toward their own roster.

Lewis and Gorman would also be rebound bets rather than straightforward upgrades. The Yankees would need to weigh the acquisition cost against the chance that either player returns to better form. A trade could address the position, but it wouldn’t remove the uncertainty that comes with replacing McMahon.

The lineup’s floor is the bigger concern

New York’s offense needs more support across the lineup. After Judge went down with a rib injury, the Yankees recorded a 93 wRC+, tied for the fifth-worst mark in the majors over that stretch. McMahon’s production made third base one clear weakness, but his replacement alone won’t resolve the broader vulnerability.

The choice is difficult because both paths carry a cost. Retaining McMahon means accepting the possibility that his weak offense and diminished range continue. Releasing him or trading for an upgrade could consume money and roster assets the Yankees need elsewhere. Sato and Paredes stand out as potential targets, but neither makes the budget issue disappear.

New York has to decide how much uncertainty it can afford at third base while rebuilding the bullpen and sorting out second base, Stanton’s roster spot and Judge’s supporting cast. McMahon’s 2026 season doesn’t make the answer obvious. It does make clear that the Yankees need more from the position if they want a deeper playoff run in 2027.

Photo courtesy of Brad Penner, Imagn Images

Source: AJ Eustace · www.mlbtraderumors.com