Ohio State Beats Indiana 19-15, but Julian Sayin’s Injury Puts Its Season on a New Track

| 5 min read

Ohio State left Bloomington with a win it badly needed and a question it can’t avoid: how does the offense function without Julian Sayin? The Buckeyes beat Indiana 19-15 on Saturday, but Ryan Day said afterward that Sayin will miss “several weeks” with an upper-body injury. His throwing shoulder was later seen in a sling.

That changes the feel of a victory that came down to a narrow margin. Indiana receiver Nick Marsh appeared to have a chance at the winning touchdown in the north end zone, but his foot came down near the boundary. Ohio State survived, and the result gives the Buckeyes a valuable win before their schedule gets tougher. The cost is a likely stretch with backup Luke Fahey, who entered in emergency action against Indiana.

A win with playoff weight

Ohio State’s loss at Texas already left little room for error. After a bye, the Buckeyes face USC, then Oregon and ranked Northwestern, with Nebraska also on the schedule. Another loss would make that run far more difficult. A win over Indiana, by contrast, gives Ohio State a strong result to point to as the season develops.

Day said his team “found a way to win the game in the fourth quarter.” That matters, especially given how close Indiana came. The College Football Playoff selection committee considers injuries in its discussions, according to the account of a mock selection exercise earlier in the week. If Ohio State loses while Sayin is out, his absence may help explain the result, but the Buckeyes will still need to show they can compete without him.

Saturday offered both reasons for confidence and reasons for concern. Sayin struggled against Indiana’s pressure, completing 52 percent of 29 passes and throwing two interceptions. One came on a badly overthrown ball; the other was tipped. The Hoosiers repeatedly used stunts to disrupt him, and their pass rush made the pocket uncomfortable throughout the game.

Defense kept Ohio State alive

The Buckeyes’ defense supplied the steadier performance. Ohio State’s defensive line disrupted an Indiana rushing attack that has been a defining strength under Curt Cignetti. The Hoosiers gained just 73 yards on 29 carries, averaging 2.5 yards per attempt—their lowest rushing output since their 2024 College Football Playoff loss to Notre Dame.

That kind of run defense gives Ohio State a foundation as the offense adjusts. It won’t answer every question raised by Sayin’s injury, but it showed the Buckeyes can make a game difficult for an opponent even when their quarterback is under pressure and the offense isn’t clicking.

Jeremiah Smith made the defining play

Ohio State’s decisive moment came from Jeremiah Smith, whose route on a critical fourth-down play wasn’t the one Sayin expected. Smith said afterward that Sayin trusted him anyway. The quarterback sent the ball toward the south end zone, where Smith adjusted, slipped between two Indiana defenders and came down with the touchdown.

It was not a perfect throw or a cleanly executed route. It was a remarkable catch by one of college football’s most prominent receivers, and it proved to be the difference. Smith’s ability to turn a broken-looking play into a score gave Ohio State the margin it needed to leave Bloomington with the win.

Day called his team “resilient against a good defense,” and the description fits the result. Ohio State didn’t look complete: Sayin was uneven, the offense faced persistent pressure, and Indiana nearly stole the game. But the Buckeyes defended the run, came through in the fourth quarter and secured a result that should strengthen their playoff résumé.

The bye arrives at a useful moment. Day and his staff have time to assess Sayin’s recovery and prepare Fahey for a demanding stretch. Ohio State can take confidence from the defense and Smith’s game-changing catch, but its next challenge is clear: preserve its playoff position while its starting quarterback is sidelined.

Source: William Rodriguez · www.foxsports.com