Devils’ Goaltending Could Limit Their Stanley Cup Hopes

| 5 min read

New Jersey’s offense can keep it in games against almost anyone. The harder question is whether the Devils can win when the scoring slows down. With Jake Allen, Nico Daws and David Rittich in the crease, the team has a serviceable group, but its goaltending could become the gap between reaching the playoffs and making a serious run.

Jack Hughes, Luke Hughes, Nico Hischier and Jesper Bratt give the Devils a high-end core, with Timo Meier adding another scoring threat. That talent puts New Jersey in a competitive window, especially in a weakened Metropolitan Division. Yet the Devils aren’t widely viewed as a championship contender, and their current roster offers little assurance that they can win tight games when their offense isn’t carrying them.

A capable group with a high ceiling to clear

Allen is an experienced NHL goaltender who has shown he can perform well in limited stretches. At 36, though, a full season of heavy work could make it difficult for him to be at his best if he’s asked to start in the playoffs. Daws is still establishing himself in the league, while Rittich can provide depth and cover as a third option.

That trio may be adequate over the regular season. It’s harder to picture it carrying New Jersey through a playoff round. The Devils could control possession and create the better chances, then lose because they don’t get a timely save. That risk grows if defensive weaknesses leave the goalies facing dangerous opportunities.

Average goaltending can blunt the value of a powerful attack. New Jersey may find itself needing five goals on some nights, whether because of poor netminding or simply a lack of extra saves. And when the team’s scoring dries up, it will need to win 1-0 and 2-1 games—the sort of results that championship teams can produce even during an offensive slump.

The Markstrom trade left a decision unresolved

The Devils moved Jacob Markstrom to the Florida Panthers in the offseason after an inconsistent spell in New Jersey. The trade was understandable, but it left an open question about who would take over as the team’s starter. When Connor Hellebuyck of the Winnipeg Jets became available, that question seemed newly urgent. General manager Sunny Mehta has said he’s comfortable with the team’s goaltending situation.

Mehta’s position has a practical case behind it. Goaltending is unpredictable: an expensive, established starter can slump, while an unheralded option can catch fire. Andrew Hammond’s run in Ottawa remains a reminder that a goalie can outperform expectations for a stretch. New Jersey may be betting that Allen, Daws and Rittich can provide enough at a lower cost than Markstrom, or that a better fit will emerge later.

The gamble cuts both ways. Trading Markstrom took away one possible answer, and moving ahead with the current group creates another risk. The Carolina Hurricanes won the Stanley Cup with Brandon Bussi, Frederik Andersen and Pyotr Kochetkov, but their roster is deeper than New Jersey’s and their playing system is distinctive. Their success doesn’t establish that the Devils can expect the same results from a similar-looking collection of goalies.

Development and workload both matter

Giving Daws room to develop makes sense. Treating him as a dependable playoff starter before he has established himself would be a much larger bet. Allen’s experience can help steady the group, but his age makes workload management important. Together, those considerations leave New Jersey without a clear first choice who can reliably shoulder the postseason load.

The Devils don’t need to make a move simply because their current goalies lack star billing. Mehta is right to account for how volatile the position can be. But if New Jersey wants its offensive core to have a credible chance at a deep run, the front office should keep watch on goalie situations around the league. A legitimate starter who can share the work with Allen would give the team more room to survive its inevitable scoring droughts—and make its playoff ambitions look more convincing.

Source: Josh Cybulski · www.prohockeyrumors.com