Pete Crow-Armstrong, Ceddanne Rafaela and Andy Pages Make the Case for MLB’s Best Center Fielder
Pete Crow-Armstrong may be the center fielder most fans remember from this season. His spectacular catches and standout range make a strong case for the best defensive season in baseball. But the numbers split the verdict: Ceddanne Rafaela led Defensive Runs Saved, Crow-Armstrong topped MLB’s Fielding Run Value, and Andy Pages led Runs Effectively Defended. Each ranked first in one measure and third in another.
That disagreement gives the 21st annual Fielding Bible Awards, scheduled to be announced Thursday, October 22, an unusually close center-field race. The three metrics capture different parts of defense, from reaching balls to throwing out runners and avoiding costly mistakes. The results don’t point to a single obvious winner.
Three measures, three leaders
| Crow-Armstrong | Rafaela | Pages | |
| Defensive Runs Saved | 3rd | 1st | 2nd |
| Fielding Run Value | 1st | 2nd | 3rd |
| Runs Effectively Defended | 2nd | 3rd | 1st |
Defensive Runs Saved, or DRS, is developed by Sports Info Solutions. MLB’s Fielding Run Value put Crow-Armstrong first, with Rafaela and Pages next. Chris Dial’s Runs Effectively Defended (RED), a component of the Sabermetric Defensive Index used in Gold Glove voting, ranked Pages first, Crow-Armstrong second and Rafaela third.
Here’s the thing: the gap between a player’s best skill and his total value can be decisive. Crow-Armstrong’s range stands out across systems, while Rafaela pairs strong range with valuable throws. Pages brings a different profile, with a high assist total that helped close the distance.
Crow-Armstrong’s range comes with a DRS trade-off
The case for Crow-Armstrong starts with how much ground he covers. He led center fielders in DRS’s Range component, and also topped the league in Outs Above Average and RED’s range component. His outfield jump figures were the best in MLB, according to Statcast’s outfield jump leaderboard.
His 18 Range Runs Saved were the most by a center fielder since Harrison Bader recorded 18 in 2021. That was the first season DRS accounted for outfielders’ positioning before the pitch. The total is exceptional, though it doesn’t settle whether Crow-Armstrong’s range has no peer: previous Fielding Bible Award winners Kevin Kiermaier, Kevin Pillar and Byron Buxton have also made compelling cases as elite defenders.
DRS didn’t add value for Crow-Armstrong’s arm, unlike some other measures. The system evaluates outfield arms through results: throws that record outs carry substantial value, while holds—when a runner takes only one base on a single or two on a double—earn a smaller amount. Fielding depth matters, too. A hold or out made from medium depth counts more than one made from a shallower position.
Runners advanced against Crow-Armstrong 52% of the time, five percentage points better than the MLB average. He recorded five assists, though, and only two came without help from a cutoff man. Those totals trailed Rafaela and Pages. That doesn’t mean his arm was poor; it helps explain why DRS valued it differently.
Small mistakes affect the DRS totals
DRS also includes Good Fielding Plays and Defensive Misplays. Sports Info Solutions’ Data Scouts score about 30 types of positive plays and 60 types of misplays and errors, applying rules originally designed by Bill James. The system assigns each event a fraction of a run. For outfielders, a good play might mean cutting off a ball before a batter can stretch a single into a double. A misplay might involve slipping or throwing past a cutoff man.
Those events reduced Crow-Armstrong’s total by two runs. Pages gained three runs in this category, while Rafaela was even. The difference between Crow-Armstrong and Pages was five runs. Crow-Armstrong had eight misplays involving mishandled hits, plus six wasted throws after hits, errors or sacrifice flies. Those 14 plays cost opportunities to record an out or prevent a runner from taking a base. Rafaela had eight combined; Pages had four.
They’re the kinds of moments that may fade from a fan’s memory, while a leaping catch stays vivid. But the scoring system counts both. Crow-Armstrong’s season remains a strong contender for the best in the field; the supporting numbers simply leave room for disagreement.
Rafaela combines range and arm value
Rafaela’s argument is balance. His range value sits below Crow-Armstrong’s, and his arm value falls short of Pages’ in some measures, but he rates highly in both. He won the Fielding Bible Award last year with 20 Runs Saved, while Crow-Armstrong finished with 15. Rafaela led DRS again this season through a similar mix: extra plays on shallow and medium fly balls, solid work on deep balls, and productive throws.
Runners advanced against Rafaela at a 44% rate, the lowest among center fielders. The MLB average was 57%. He led American League center fielders with eight assists, the third-highest total across MLB; six came without a cutoff man. That matched his assist total from the previous season. Fielding Run Value assigns less value to his arm than DRS does, reflecting a difference in how the systems evaluate defense.
Statcast also places Rafaela among the top center fielders for getting jumps on fly balls and for arm strength. My read is that his case rests less on one defining skill than on how consistently he contributes in several parts of the job.
Pages makes his case with his throwing arm
Pages is close to Rafaela in the combined picture and finished ahead of Crow-Armstrong in both DRS and RED. His range numbers are strong—fifth in DRS’s Range component—but well behind Crow-Armstrong’s. His arm supplies the difference. Pages had 14 outfield assists, six more than Rafaela and nine more than Crow-Armstrong.
Runners advanced against Pages 54% of the time, a higher rate than against either rival. Yet runners challenged him often, and his assist total shows that those decisions could be costly. An outfield assist has two benefits: it records an out and removes a runner from the bases. Enough assists can quickly add value in a measure such as DRS.
Pages’ strong finish follows a memorable defensive moment from last year, when his catch in Game 7 helped save the World Series. That history may make his candidacy easier to frame, but the current case comes down to the same measures used for the others: range, arm results and the small plays that accumulate across a season.
A close call among three excellent defenders
The award vote is difficult because each player’s best evidence points in a different direction. Crow-Armstrong has the clearest range advantage. Rafaela has the strongest DRS total and an effective blend of range and throwing. Pages leads in RED and stands out for his assists. The systems disagree because they weigh distinct defensive contributions differently.
The voter behind this analysis chose Rafaela, citing confidence in DRS. But a vote for Crow-Armstrong or Pages is also defensible. The practical takeaway is that the award will distinguish one winner from two equally accomplished peers; the numbers don’t erase what all three did in center field.
Mark Simon is the head of editorial for Sports Info Solutions, which created Defensive Runs Saved and originated The Fielding Bible Awards. DRS has been used to evaluate players back to 2003, and the awards have recognized defensive excellence since 2006.
The post Who’s the Best Defensive Center Fielder in Baseball? appeared first on Baseball Prospectus.
===