Padres’ 2027 Offseason Centers on Rebuilding a Thin Starting Rotation

| 5 min read

San Diego’s path back to the postseason runs through its starting rotation. The Padres closed 2026 with a 43-23 second half and the National League’s top Wild Card spot, then swept past the Cubs before falling hard to the Brewers. Their lineup should retain much of its core, but the rotation could lose several arms and has little proven depth behind it.

A rotation with more questions than answers

Free agency is set to take Robbie Ray, Walker Buehler and Casey Mize. Lucas Giolito and Griffin Canning also appear likely to depart: both have mutual options, which rarely get exercised by both sides and often serve mainly to defer part of a player’s pay. Michael King has an opt-out he is expected to use, while San Diego must decide whether to exercise Nick Pivetta’s $14MM club option.

If those departures materialize, the rotation’s on-paper group includes Joe Musgrove, Randy Vásquez, JP Sears and Jhony Brito. That list offers little certainty. Musgrove missed both the 2025 and 2026 seasons while recovering from Tommy John surgery. He returned for three postseason innings, but a full starter’s workload in 2027 would be a steep ask; president of baseball operations A.J. Preller has acknowledged the workload concern.

Vásquez posted a respectable ERA, though his 14.8% strikeout rate was among the lowest for pitchers with at least 140 innings. Only Tomoyuki Sugano of the Rockies was lower. Sears spent most of 2026 in Triple-A and recorded a 7.49 ERA there. Brito’s 2.97 ERA in the minors was more encouraging, but came with a 16.2% strikeout rate. San Diego needs multiple additions, and at least one will need to offer dependable innings.

Payroll limits the room to maneuver

The scale of those needs collides with a heavily committed payroll. The Padres owe $180.1MM for 2027, with total future commitments of $1.0271 billion. Manny Machado is owed $280MM through 2033, including $35MM in signing bonus obligations; Fernando Tatis Jr. has $266MM due through 2034, and Xander Bogaerts $175MM through 2033. Jackson Merrill’s $135MM deal also runs through 2034.

Other sizable obligations include King at $66MM through 2028, Jake Cronenworth at $48MM through 2030 and Musgrove at $20MM through 2027. Yuki Matsui has $13.5MM remaining through 2028, with opt-out opportunities, while Sung-Mun Song’s $12MM commitment runs through 2029 and includes an opt-out after 2028. Wandy Peralta can take a $4.45MM player option for 2027.

The club’s available spending remains the central uncertainty. Payroll climbed under Peter Seidler and peaked in 2023; after his death, San Diego pulled back. The Juan Soto trade sent the star to the Yankees to reduce costs and add rotation depth, while other deals drained the farm system. The Padres have continued to bring in free agents, but some contracts have used backloaded salaries and option buyouts to manage when cash is paid. Pivetta’s and King’s contracts include backloading and opt-outs; deals for Germán Márquez, Canning and Giolito use mutual-option buyouts to push payments later.

Position players and bullpen face smaller resets

San Diego’s 48-48 first half gave way to a strong finish, and the club’s task now is to preserve enough of that roster while addressing the pitching gap. Several position players are free agents, including Ramon Laureano, Ty France, Luis Rengifo, Austin Hays and Miguel Andujar. Jason Adam and Adrián Morejón are among the relievers who could also leave. The bullpen may lose pieces, but the rotation remains the more urgent weakness.

Arbitration adds another layer to roster decisions. Projected salaries include $8.1MM for Mason Miller, $6.5MM for Gavin Sheets, $2.8MM for JP Sears, $2.6MM for Freddy Fermin and $1.7MM for Luis Campusano. Jeremiah Estrada is projected at $1.3MM, while Bryan Hoeing and Jhony Brito are each at $800K. Hoeing and Sears are listed as possible non-tender candidates, making Sears’ place on the projected rotation particularly uncertain.

San Diego has the stars and a recent second-half run to build on. But with its most dependable rotation options potentially leaving and Musgrove’s workload unclear, the offseason’s defining question is whether the front office can add enough starting depth within a payroll already committed well into the future.

Source: Darragh McDonald · www.mlbtraderumors.com