Luke Holman’s Arizona Fall League Run Offers an Early Read on His Return

| 5 min read
John E. Sokolowski-Imagn Images

For Luke Holman, the Arizona Fall League is serving as more than a showcase. It’s a chance to build innings and see how his arsenal holds up after elbow surgery and a season disrupted by injury. So far, the results have been striking: the Cincinnati Reds right-hander has given up one run in nine innings across three starts for the Peoria Desert Dogs, with 15 strikeouts, four hits allowed and one walk.

His latest outing offered a particularly encouraging glimpse. Against a Scottsdale Scorpions lineup featuring prospects Zyhir Hope, Bryce Rainer and Nathan Flewelling, Holman worked four scoreless innings on 52 pitches.

That performance fits the early scouting read from Eric Longenhagen, FanGraphs’ lead prospect analyst. Holman, a 23-year-old Reading, Pennsylvania native drafted 71st overall by Cincinnati in 2024 out of Louisiana State University, has shown a fastball sitting 92–94 mph with glove-side command and a plus curveball in the 78–82 mph range.

“He looks good,” Longenhagen said. He described Holman using fastballs and mid-80s cutter-sliders inside against left-handed hitters, then turning to curveballs below the zone. Longenhagen sees the potential for a back-end starter, but wants to know how Holman handles hitters a second and third time through the order as his outings stretch toward six innings. He’ll also be watching how the pitcher’s arm strength develops through a full-season routine.

A return built around innings

Holman hasn’t had much chance to establish that routine. After two effective professional outings in April 2025, his elbow gave out. Tommy John surgery ended his season, and an unrelated groin issue limited him to four appearances in the Arizona Complex League this year. He missed nearly the entire campaign.

“The Reds wanted me to be 100% healthy, then go at it — basically be ready for the Fall League — but it wasn’t the arm,” Holman said. “My arm actually feels as good as it’s ever felt.”

His first AFL outing came October 5 against the Salt River Rafters. He allowed his only run of the fall in that two-inning appearance. Since then, he has been able to extend his outings, reaching four innings in his most recent start.

Holman is ranked 17th in the Cincinnati system with a 40 FV. He says his fastball’s velocity floor has risen since surgery, and that his curveball feels back to its previous form. The slider, which he described as more of a gyro shape than a sweeper, remains a work in progress. His splitter has given him another option against left-handed hitters.

“I had a really bad changeup, so I started throwing a splitter a couple years ago,” he said. “It will knuckle a little bit here and there, but it’s a true splitter and has been pretty nasty for me.”

The curveball sets the terms

The curve is the pitch that may define Holman’s profile. Longenhagen previously described it as “a huge mid-70s rainbow curveball that looks like it is headed to the backstop and then bends into the zone.” Holman says he has thrown it since childhood, first working on its shape before learning to pair it with the ride on his fastball.

Its value isn’t limited to swings and misses. The curve can begin high enough to discourage a hitter from offering, then drop into the strike zone. Once Holman has shown he can land it for a strike, he can bury it for a chase or use it to change the hitter’s expectations.

“Getting it in there, showing that I can land it for strike, kind of lets me [then] do whatever I want with it,” he said. “I can bounce it, or throw it wherever.”

Holman isn’t a power pitcher, which makes the shape and command of his offspeed pitches central to his prospects as a starter. He leaned on the slider in college, where his rotation-mates at LSU included Kade Anderson and Gage Jump, but says the pitch has been inconsistent since Tommy John surgery.

“I want to throw what I’m good at,” Holman said. “The curveball has been really good for me.” His aim is to get all four pitches working for strikes, and the Fall League is giving him a chance to rebuild that mix one inning at a time. The next meaningful test will be whether the stuff and command hold as his workload grows.

Source

Source: David Laurila · blogs.fangraphs.com