How Baseball Scouts Combine Data, Video and Live Looks to Evaluate Players

| 5 min read

Scouting is less about finding one perfect metric than combining imperfect evidence: video, data, live looks, and an understanding of how a player might develop. In a FanGraphs chat on October 20, 2026, Brendan Gawlowski’s answers kept returning to that point. Some evaluations shifted with new information; others held steady. And sometimes the best view of a tool comes from being at the ballpark.

How evaluations change

11:03 AM — Brendan Gawlowski: “Hello everybody, let's get to it.”

11:05 AM — Anonymous Member #46: What can an evaluator learn from the Rays and Brewers, given their sustained success acquiring and developing players?

Brendan Gawlowski: They’re leading examples of holistic evaluation, with strong front offices, scouting staffs, and player development operations working “hand in glove.”

11:07 AM — Jeremy Bowers: Why do evaluations and rankings change over the offseason when there doesn’t seem to be much new information? How do you assess a player or organization when you have a fresh perspective but no new looks?

Brendan Gawlowski: A full year of information is available to review. It may change a projection, or it may not, but the offseason is still a useful time to revisit the evidence. That work includes video and data analysis; even a player who looks much the same might have added a pitch worth checking on video.

11:09 AM — jdbolick: Has seeing Kade Anderson throw his four-seam fastball with the MLB ball changed your opinion?

Brendan Gawlowski: He wishes they’d been less bullish in the midseason update. Anderson’s fastball grade will drop.

11:11 AM — Domingo Ayala: Older scouting reports gave Jurickson Profar a present 70 grade for shortstop defense. Was that a misread, or did his defense change?

Brendan Gawlowski: Injuries may have played a role, and the 70 grade might have been too high. He also cautioned that he was a novice at the time.

11:14 AM — Domingo Ayala: When Mickey Moniak was drafted first overall, a report said he looked less athletic when he arrived at spring camp. Did Gawlowski remember seeing him that spring?

Brendan Gawlowski: He hadn’t seen Moniak then. But Moniak is still playing some center field in major league games, ten years after being drafted, so Gawlowski wasn’t convinced that athleticism was the problem.

Tools are easier to grade in context

11:05 AM — Charles Bengal Tiger: Which catcher offers the best chance of a solid major league career for a long-term dynasty roster: Leo Bernal, Vahn Lackey, or Nathan Flewelling?

Brendan Gawlowski: Lackey, though he likes all three.

11:06 AM — Charles Bengal Tiger: How has Charles Davalan looked at second base?

Brendan Gawlowski: The early signs are promising. Davalan has the athleticism and range for the position, but needs more repetitions.

11:16 AM — mbushskbum: After attending the Arizona Fall League tripleheader in Goodyear on Saturday and games in Glendale at Salt River the next day, the reader was impressed by Dax Kilby’s speed and the way he hit a triple and a ground-rule double hard. Why does FanGraphs grade Kilby’s speed at 55 while MLB and Baseball America give him a 60? What goes into the grade?

Brendan Gawlowski: Home-to-first time is the main reference point. He may adjust the grade by half a step depending on how playable the speed looks. In-person scouting can reveal a player’s first step on defense or on the bases, while some video feeds make accurate run times difficult to judge.

11:18 AM — Brendan Gawlowski: He recalled a scout who got into serious trouble after assigning 60 run grades to 30 runners based on video. The scout hadn’t realized the camera angles weren’t synchronized.

11:22 AM — mbushskbum: How does Gawlowski assess Nathan Flewelling’s catcher defense, especially his framing? What does he look for when grading framing?

Brendan Gawlowski: Framing is easier to judge on video, where he can focus on it without the distractions of being at the ballpark. He looks for mobility, a low stance, strong wrists, and limited head movement. If the physical tools are there but the technique needs work, he’s comfortable projecting improvement. Flewelling already does several things well: he stays low and can funnel pitches toward the plate from different directions.

Prospects, pitches, and plans

11:11 AM — bdolven: What’s Jared Grimdlinger’s likely path? Is pitching off the table, and how quickly might he move?

Brendan Gawlowski: Los Angeles Angels sources say the organization plans to try him as a two-way player. That route could slow his progress, but Gawlowski called it exciting.

11:13 AM — Charles Bengal Tiger: Who is the Dodgers’ next good homegrown starting pitcher?

Brendan Gawlowski: Zazueta is the current front-runner.

11:18 AM — kingkash7788: How much has Nimmala risen over the past week or so?

Brendan Gawlowski: His standing is holding steady. He might be down a tick, and Gawlowski isn’t ready to move him off shortstop, though he sees that possibility more each time he watches him.

11:24 AM — George: In Gawlowski’s October 10 Arizona Fall League pitcher notes, he wrote that Susana had split his breaking ball into two shapes. They had looked more blended in Triple-A. Had Gawlowski heard how that happened in the Fall League, or whether it was intentional?

Brendan Gawlowski: The velocity gap between Susana’s slowest and fastest breakers was wide enough to suggest two pitches, though he may simply have been varying the speed of one. Either way, Gawlowski likes that Susana can change the look.

11:25 AM — war2d2: A group of friends was starting to plan its annual spring training trip. Would there be games in late February the following year, while minor leaguers were still under contract? If plans fell through, the group was considering Cape Cod or the Arizona Fall League in October and wanted to know which might be more enjoyable.

Brendan Gawlowski: It was a difficult year to plan, and he had no better predictions than anyone else. His guess, as a “hopeless optimist,” was a situation similar to 2022, perhaps with a few games missed. For travelers able to wait until a few weeks beforehand, he suggested that hotels might be a good deal and major league games lightly attended. Those willing to visit only the backfields could plan ahead.

11:28 AM — Wright Abbot: Most of the Orioles players in the Fall League seem to be doing well. Has anything in particular caught Gawlowski’s attention?

Scouting still needs people, not just data

The case for rebuilding scouting departments is stronger than a single World Series matchup: Brendan Gawlowski pointed to a mix of reasons teams cut staff. Some executives believe the data is good enough to replace scouts; others dislike the different perspective scouts bring. And, he said, some scouts make a poor case for themselves. Alex Remington raised the question after seeing the Mets add scouts, but Gawlowski didn’t predict whether other clubs would follow. That tension shows up in how prospects are evaluated. Asked by swood which players he’d rated too highly, Gawlowski said he’s most frustrated when data points mislead: metal bat exit velocities can receive too much weight, and a fastball can get an inflated grade because of shape produced with a minor league ball. He said Dylan Beavers’ writeup offers a trail of reasoning for his evaluation. On the minor league ball itself, he expects it may move back toward its earlier behavior, but admitted he doesn’t know; the league has struggled to produce consistent baseballs.

What the evaluations say about individual players

The player assessments were often provisional. On Petey Bienel’s question about Cayden Wallace, Gawlowski said a 40 grade felt about right at first glance, though he’d want to assess the defense before settling on it. Wallace has reached the AA power grade Gawlowski had projected for him, but his approach remains a weakness. He was more encouraged by Honeycutt’s bat: the impact looked closer to a 40 grade than a major contribution, but Honeycutt didn’t look overmatched. Ace Reese is projected to end up at first base or left field. Early reports from a couple of scouts suggest he looked more like a hitter than expected, though Gawlowski cautioned that the 2026 draft class has yielded only scattered impressions so far—not enough to conclude that a team made a major mistake. He hadn’t seen Aidan Miller in the Arizona Fall League (AFL), despite hearing Keith Law say Miller looked good there; Gawlowski said Eric had seen Miller a couple of times. For Colson Montgomery, StuShea asked whether the White Sox should give him another year. Gawlowski said yes: Montgomery’s numbers fell sharply around the time he was injured, and he believes Montgomery may have played through something in the second half. On Josiah Ragsdale, he said his view was much the same as in the midseason evaluation, linking to the earlier [Milwaukee Brewers trade-deadline prospects guide](https://blogs.fangraphs.com/trade-deadline-prospects-guide-milwaukee-brewers/). David Hagaman’s ceiling, Gawlowski said in response to Rayball, is a No. 3 starter. He expects Hagaman to receive a 45 grade this winter, perhaps 45+, and said he could reach the desert next year, with a 2027 or 2028 arrival as plausible ETAs. Gawlowski also volunteered that ETA is the projection he spends the least time on: tools and performance are hard enough to project, and a player’s timeline depends on more than talent. A question from apeloton about the Red Sox’s possible Trevor Story–Arias situation drew a pragmatic answer. If Story is healthy and plays well at shortstop, that’s a good outcome; if not, Arias should be nearly ready for the role the team wants him to fill. Gawlowski added that the arrangement could, cynically, delay Arias’ service-time clock. On Texas, he reframed Honkus Wagner’s question about whether Walcott had played enough shortstop in the AFL: Walcott will need to keep proving he can handle the position throughout his career. The questioner also wondered how the Rangers would manage Jung and Seager next year.

Projection has limits

Pirates Hurdles wondered why Derek Curiel, coming from LSU, didn’t play in the minors this year, and compared the decision with the approach taken with Murf Gray. Gawlowski said it’s fairly typical for first-round picks not to report to A-ball late in the season; some do, some don’t, and he wouldn’t read much into Curiel’s absence. The same caution applies to relief prospects. Asked by beanbong whether postseason workloads should affect future value (FV) grades for late-inning relievers, Gawlowski called the question interesting and stressed how difficult relievers are to project. Top relief prospects don’t reliably become dominant closers, and he asked how anyone could have predicted that Cade Smith would cut his walk rate in half upon reaching the majors. Smith, the questioner noted, had run out of gas in the postseason despite throwing more innings than any Cleveland pitcher except Messick and Williams. Gawlowski said he’s increasingly projecting minor league starters into relief roles while assigning them higher FVs than he might have a few years ago. Some answers were deliberately short. Asked by Charles Bengal Tiger where Ace Reese will play, Gawlowski said first base or left field. Asked by dan norman lear who would start in the Rockies’ outfield on Opening Day 2027, whenever that falls, he answered Carrigg. For a dynasty league’s first overall pick, he said he isn’t a fantasy player but would consider PCA, Witt, Elly or Caminero, depending on risk tolerance and positional scarcity. A few questions were more about the experience of following the sport. In answer to mbushskbum’s request for backfield advice, Gawlowski explained that clubs divide minor leaguers into four or five teams, which play near the stadium in most—but not all—cases. The Athletics, Giants and Reds/Guardians were exceptions he named. Usually two games run at once, pairing either A and A+ teams or AA and AAA teams. There are few fans; scouts, family members and autograph seekers make up more of the crowd. His verdict: it’s a good time. The fragment also included a brief exchange about NBA opening day. higginsford asked whether Gawlowski was watching the day game on Peacock; the excerpt ends before his reply. Earlier, an opening comment said Honeycutt had been a pleasant surprise, with modest rather than huge impact and no sign of being overmatched at the plate.

Prospects, projections and the limits of certainty

The best reminder here is that even a strong prospect grade can’t protect a player from being exposed. Brendan Gawlowski pointed to Tovar: after a 3.5-win 2024 season, he said, he would have been stunned to hear that two years later Tovar’s walk and strikeout numbers would improve while his wRC+ fell to 55. Gawlowski’s explanation was blunt: opponents found a way to exploit his approach. “Can’t miss” is a label scouts should use sparingly. There’s a brighter ceiling for Kilby. Gawlowski’s most optimistic projection is a .300 hitter with some power who plays above-average defense at shortstop. He also expects five to 10 players from the back end of the top 100 to climb next year, naming Kilby as a sure bet and Luis Hernandez as a possibility. Michael Arroyo could rise too: he has seen some big-league action and played well, and Gawlowski said he’d argue for ranking him ahead of Celesten. Jake Cook’s first professional season drew a more muted assessment. His speed showed up better on the bases than it had in college, a positive sign, but Gawlowski described his overall trajectory as flat or slightly down.

How teams weigh players

The conversation also touched on a familiar roster-building puzzle: whether a dominant relief arm is more valuable in a seven-game playoff series than a No. 3 starter with a 4.00 FIP. Gawlowski’s answer complicated the comparison: the No. 3 starter might be able to serve as the fireman reliever himself. It’s a useful reminder that player value can depend on how a team deploys him, though the exchange doesn’t settle how much that should affect projections made before the season. Amateur scouting works on a similar balance. Top picks command concentrated attention; Gawlowski said multiple decision-makers may personally scout and speak with players expected to sign for seven figures. But teams also devote people to finding late-round talent. The biggest investments get more eyes, while organizational depth still depends on discovering players outside the early rounds.

The rest of the board

Asked about Colorado’s outfield, Gawlowski initially misread a question about the corners as one about center field. His corrected guess was that the Rockies would bring back McCarthy and Moniak in the corners—an answer he called boring. A reader wondered whether Veen or Condon might make appealing trade pieces for a pitching-rich club, while questioning whether such clubs can really exist given how many pitchers teams use each year. The transcript leaves that trade question open. There was one brief detour into basketball. Gawlowski’s objection was the uncertainty around block, charge, or no call: “just a vibe.” A sharp line, though it’s more a personal complaint than an argument about the sport.
Source: Brendan Gawlowski · blogs.fangraphs.com