Matt Donohue Returns to Premier League VAR Duty After Manchester Derby Error

| 5 min read

Matt Donohue is returning to Premier League VAR duty after a high-profile mistake in September’s Manchester derby. His assignment as assistant VAR for Coventry’s match against Fulham on Saturday puts him back in the league’s officiating rotation after he missed three match rounds.

The decision brings a personnel update to a controversy that exposed how a VAR review can settle on one offside question while overlooking another. Donohue and assistant Blake Antrobus correctly established that Erling Haaland was onside when he scored for Manchester City at Old Trafford. They failed to account for the effect of Enzo Fernandez, who was in an offside position and appeared to interfere with Manchester United defender Lisandro Martinez.

What the review missed

The incident came in the 59th minute of the September 13 derby. City were down to 10 men when Haaland turned in a cross. The assistant referee initially raised the flag for offside against the striker, but semi-automated technology showed Haaland was onside, and the goal was allowed to stand.

That check answered whether Haaland himself was offside. It did not settle whether Fernandez, who moved to reach the same cross, had committed an offside offence by affecting an opponent. Fernandez did not touch the ball, but his attempt to play it appeared to influence Martinez’s defending. Under the laws of the game, a player in an offside position can be penalised for interfering with an opponent even without making contact with the ball.

The Premier League Match Centre’s explanation on X focused on the distinction. It said VAR had found Haaland onside and judged that Fernandez “didn't play the ball.” Pro Ref later acknowledged that the review should also have assessed the likely impact of Fernandez’s position.

In a statement issued hours after City’s win, Pro Ref said the on-field decision had been offside against Haaland, who was then found to be onside. Because Fernandez did not play the ball, whether he was interfering with play was a subjective decision. The VAR, the organisation said, failed to recognise the likely impact of Fernandez’s position and should have recommended an on-field review. Pro Ref contacted United to acknowledge what it called an “error of judgment” and said the incident would be reviewed.

Webb’s explanation of the mistake

Pro Ref chief refereeing officer Howard Webb later described the review as an example of “tunnel vision.” Donohue became focused on Haaland’s position and, after finding the striker onside by three centimetres, did not properly assess Fernandez across the full attacking possession phase. Webb said the rest of the VAR team should have helped redirect the review.

“The VAR gets super focused on Haaland,” Webb said on Match Officials Mic'd Up. He added that the VAR had established Haaland was onside but had not “truly evaluate[d] the full impact of Fernandez.” Webb said he was “really disappointed” with the decision and concluded: “This goal should have been disallowed.”

The released audio shows how the review narrowed. After confirming Haaland was onside, the VAR said he needed to check the full attacking phase, then checked whether Iliman Ndiaye was onside earlier in the move. The discussion returned to Fernandez’s lack of a touch: “No touch there,” the VAR said, before confirming the goal. The review ended with the referee being told to change the decision to goal.

That sequence captures the problem Pro Ref identified. The lack of contact was treated as the decisive point, while the question of whether Fernandez’s movement affected Martinez did not receive sufficient scrutiny. An on-field review would have allowed the referee to assess that subjective element.

Return to the Premier League schedule

Donohue has continued officiating in the EFL since the derby, taking charge of Derby against Wrexham in the Championship on October 10 and Southampton against Bolton last weekend. His return to the Premier League comes in an assistant VAR role for Coventry’s home match against Fulham.

Antrobus, who worked with Donohue on the derby review, returned to a Premier League match last Saturday as an assistant referee for Newcastle’s home fixture against Aston Villa. The two officials have therefore had different routes back into top-flight appointments since the Old Trafford incident.

The original match also drew criticism over a separate decision involving Phil Foden. Sky Sports commentators questioned the refereeing during the game, with Gary Neville predicting a public apology from Pro Ref. Jamie Carragher said the officials appeared to have concentrated too heavily on Haaland’s position, while Micah Richards argued Fernandez was challenging for the ball. Roy Keane said United had been punished despite holding a good defensive line.

Those reactions reflected the central concern: confirming Haaland was onside did not, by itself, establish that the goal was legal. Fernandez’s position and movement required a separate judgment about their effect on play. Pro Ref’s later clarification accepted that the VAR team had not made that assessment adequately.

The test for the next review

Donohue’s return does not change the decision made at Old Trafford, which gave City the lead in a match they won. It does put a spotlight on the distinction at the heart of the error: technology can identify a player’s position, while officials still need to judge what that player did and whether it affected an opponent.

For Premier League VAR teams, the practical takeaway is to carry an offside check through the whole attacking phase, even after the initial flag has been overturned. In Donohue’s next assignment, the scrutiny will be less about his presence in the booth than whether the review team keeps every relevant player and action in view.

The Manchester derby incident at Old Trafford on September 13

Howard Webb’s explanation of the VAR review

Coverage of the Phil Foden decision in the derby

Source: John Miller · www.skysports.com