NFL Week 6: J.J. McCarthy, Chuba Hubbard and Evan Williams Make Their Mark

| 5 min read

Week 6 offered three different reminders that NFL games can turn on contributions from players outside the usual spotlight. J.J. McCarthy brought the New York Giants within reach of a late tie after entering cold off the bench. Chuba Hubbard gave Carolina a reliable ground attack against Philadelphia’s formidable interior. And safety Evan Williams helped Green Bay disrupt Dak Prescott and the Dallas passing game.

McCarthy gives the Giants a late chance

McCarthy’s NFL path had taken a sharp turn before Sunday. Minnesota traded the former 10th overall pick, selected in 2024, to the Giants on September 28 for a 2027 fifth-round pick. New York needed quarterback help after Jaxson Dart suffered a season-ending knee injury, but McCarthy arrived behind Jameis Winston.

Winston’s interception with 12:28 left against New Orleans brought McCarthy into the game. The substitute quickly made a mistake of his own, throwing an interception with 10:27 remaining. That start gave little reason to expect a comeback. What followed, though, changed the shape of his afternoon.

McCarthy finished 11 of 23 for 243 yards, a touchdown and one interception. Four of his completions were explosive plays, a notable burst for a quarterback who had recorded 17 such passes across his entire NFL career before Sunday. He also led the Giants in rushing, gaining 26 yards on two carries.

The numbers came in a game that had already slipped away from New York. The Giants led 10-0 in the second quarter before the Saints scored 34 straight points. With 12 seconds left, McCarthy had a chance to tie the score at 34 with a completion to tight end Isaiah Likely in the end zone. The pass fell incomplete. McCarthy had also missed a wide-open Malik Nabers on that final play, a costly detail in an otherwise striking relief appearance.

Offensive coordinator Matt Nagy’s approach leaned on McCarthy’s strengths: pushing the ball downfield and using his legs when the pocket broke down. Next Gen Stats had McCarthy tied for the sixth-most fourth-quarter passing yards in a game this century. His 14.9 air yards per attempt and 17.2 air yards per completion were the highest marks this season among quarterbacks with at least 20 dropbacks. The aggressive profile wasn’t new; McCarthy led the NFL last year with 9.3 air yards per attempt and a 42.4% downfield throw rate.

New York coach John Harbaugh declined to settle the quarterback question immediately after the game. “It’s not even up for discussion or conversation right now,” he said when asked whether Winston or McCarthy would start next. Harbaugh praised Winston’s competitiveness while saying the decision would come after the team reviewed the game.

He also credited McCarthy for adapting to an unusual situation. The quarterback, Harbaugh said, “did a heck of a job given the circumstances,” made plays and gave the Giants a chance to win. One strong quarter doesn’t resolve the uncertainty around McCarthy’s career, but it gave the Giants fresh evidence of what his arm and mobility can produce when the offense lets him attack.

Hubbard finds room around Philadelphia’s front

Carolina’s 25-14 win over the Eagles depended on more than Bryce Young’s passing. Young completed 20 of 39 attempts for 289 yards, two touchdowns and no interceptions, but the Panthers needed another way to control the game. Hubbard supplied it with 120 yards and a rushing touchdown on 28 carries.

The matchup called for a change in direction. Philadelphia had allowed only 187 rushing yards at 3.3 yards per carry on 57 runs aimed up the middle or inside through Week 5, according to Sports Info Solutions. The Eagles’ front included Jalen Carter, Jordan Davis and Moro Ojomo, making direct attacks into the interior a difficult proposition. Runs toward the edges had been more productive for opponents: 403 yards at 4.4 per carry on 91 off-tackle or outside attempts.

Carolina adjusted accordingly. Before its Week 5 bye, Hubbard had taken 26% of his carries inside. Against Philadelphia, he hit the A-gaps just five times in 28 attempts. The shift let him work away from the Eagles’ strongest area and gave the Panthers a dependable rushing option even as the game plan met changing defensive looks.

Coach Dave Canales recalled that Hubbard opened with an 11-yard run, then described a first half in which Carolina had to keep troubleshooting against defensive coordinator Vic Fangio’s fronts. The Panthers stayed with the ground game and eventually found enough space to make it count. Canales said Hubbard was “running the ball really well right now” and that the production should complement the rest of the offense.

Through five games, the 2021 fourth-round pick from Oklahoma State had 426 rushing yards and four touchdowns on 89 carries. His performance in Philadelphia reinforced the value of a back who can handle a heavy workload and give the offense a clear answer when the defense’s interior strength dictates a different route. Carolina didn’t need Hubbard to run through the Eagles’ biggest bodies; it needed him to find space elsewhere.

Williams helps Green Bay unsettle Prescott

Green Bay’s 23-13 win over Dallas was built around a defense that repeatedly made Prescott reassess what he saw. The Packers varied their looks under defensive coordinator Jonathan Gannon, and safety Evan Williams was central to that disruption.

Prescott completed 34 of 54 passes for 258 yards, one touchdown and two interceptions, finishing with a 65.2 passer rating. Williams recorded seven solo tackles and two quarterback hits, while allowing one completion for seven yards on the single pass targeted at him. His interception came from a starting position near the line of scrimmage: he worked back into the deep third and jumped a skinny post intended for CeeDee Lamb.

The play carried real stakes. Prescott’s throw could have found Lamb for a touchdown, but Williams read the route and arrived between receiver and ball. His movement across the defense also made it harder for Prescott to identify a stable opening. The safety wasn’t simply holding his assigned spot; he was part of a coverage plan designed to give the quarterback changing pictures and close lanes as the play developed.

Williams credited Gannon’s call for putting him in position to make the interception. He said he recognized Lamb in the inside slot, where Prescott might look for a hot route near the red zone. Williams then relied on his instincts, floated into position and waited for the ball to appear. The 2024 fourth-round pick out of Oregon has found a clear role in Gannon’s defense, and this game showed how that fit can affect an opponent beyond the box score.

Green Bay’s defense held Dallas to 13 points, though several roughing-the-passer penalties against Packers defenders extended drives and drew criticism during the game. Even with those calls, the defense’s pressure on Prescott was evident in the final line and in the way Williams helped disguise coverage.

Each performance pointed to a different kind of impact: McCarthy supplied late-game energy, Hubbard gave Carolina a matchup-specific rushing answer, and Williams made Green Bay’s coverage harder to read. Week 6’s clearest lesson was that secondary contributors can alter a game when their skills line up with the problem in front of them.

Source: Doug Farrar · www.sbnation.com