Can Colson Montgomery Cut Strikeouts and Stay a White Sox Regular?

| 5 min read

Colson Montgomery’s 31 home runs and strong defense made him a 2.8-WAR player in 2026, but his strikeout rate left little margin for error. For the White Sox, the question is whether their 24-year-old shortstop can keep producing enough power while making more contact—and whether they’ll give him time to adjust.

Power and defense carry the value

Montgomery appeared in 153 games and made 638 plate appearances, leading American League shortstops with 31 homers, 87 RBIs and a .206 isolated slugging percentage. At shortstop, he added 10 Outs Above Average and ranked in the 94th percentile in Fielding Run Value, according to Statcast. FanGraphs valued the full season at 2.8 wins above replacement, a mid-pack result among qualified shortstops.

The offensive line tells a less reassuring story: .197/.282/.403, with a 91 wRC+. Montgomery struck out in 35.6% of his plate appearances, the highest rate among qualified hitters at any position. His teammate Munetaka Murakami was next at 35.4%, but the two handled their swing-and-miss risk differently. Murakami walked 16.6% of the time and posted a .347 on-base percentage and 129 wRC+. Montgomery’s 8.5% walk rate was closer to average, and he reached base less than 30% of the time.

That gap matters. A hitter who combines frequent strikeouts with few walks needs to do a lot of damage when he connects. Montgomery’s power kept his season useful, while his defense raised the floor. Yet the profile could turn quickly if either contribution slips.

The rookie season offered a clearer template

Montgomery’s 2025 debut covered 284 plate appearances, fewer than half his 2026 workload. He hit .239/.311/.529, recorded a 130 wRC+ and launched 21 home runs. His walk rate was similar to this year’s, but his strikeout rate was 29.2%—still high, though 6.4 percentage points lower.

That difference helped the power play. Alongside the improved contact rate, Montgomery posted plus defense at shortstop, worth seven Defensive Runs Saved and six Outs Above Average. He accumulated 2.7 fWAR in that half-season. The comparison suggests that he doesn’t need to become a low-strikeout hitter; he needs to make enough more contact to keep his power from carrying the entire offense.

His 2026 production is defensible on its own: 31 home runs and 2.8 fWAR are useful contributions. But the downside is substantial. If the power fades or an injury limits it, a .282 on-base percentage and a 35.6% strikeout rate could leave him a part-time contributor, even with above-average defense. The source analysis puts that fallback range around 1.0 to 1.5 fWAR.

Pitch recognition and fastballs are the pressure points

Montgomery’s swing decisions moved in the wrong direction. His chase rate rose from 30.5% to 32.4%, placing him in the 32nd percentile, and he made contact 6.8% less often on pitches outside the strike zone. FanGraphs’ chase-swing rate climbed from 19.8% to 28.4%. He also swung at “waste” pitches 9.2% of the time, up from 3.8% in 2025.

Pitchers offered fewer strikes, and Montgomery expanded the zone more often. Tightening his decisions would give him a better chance to attack pitches he can drive—and could help bring the strikeout rate back toward his rookie level.

Four-seam fastballs present a more specific challenge. Montgomery was worth plus-two run value against them in 2025, then fell to minus-13 in 2026. He hit .154 against four-seamers, with an 11.2% increase in strikeouts, an 8.7% drop in hard-hit rate and a 200-point fall in slugging percentage. They were his most common pitch by a margin of more than 20%, making the decline difficult to work around.

As a rough stylistic comparison, Montgomery’s current profile resembles Joey Gallo’s: major power and frequent strikeouts, though Montgomery walks less and defends shortstop better. Returning to his 2025 level would give him a more balanced base. The White Sox also have time to evaluate that development; he isn’t scheduled to reach arbitration until 2029 and likely won’t earn more than $5 million before 2030.

Chicago’s roster plans add a deadline

One option raised by MLBTR’s Anthony Franco in the outlet’s Offseason Outlook is trading Montgomery for starting pitching. Chicago has Sean Burke, Davis Martin and Anthony Kay available for its rotation. The team tried to add depth by acquiring Luis Castillo at the trade deadline, but he struggled over 31 innings. Castillo remains under contract for 2027, and the rotation still needs help if the White Sox want to advance further in October.

Montgomery’s longer-term place in the infield is also unsettled. Chicago selected Roch Cholowsky first overall in this year’s draft, and he could reach the majors in late 2027. Cholowsky is viewed as an excellent fielder, which may eventually move Montgomery off shortstop.

For now, Montgomery’s power and glove give Chicago a productive regular. His next step is more selective swings and a better plan against fastballs. If he can recover some of the contact he showed in 2025, his bat has room to support his defense; if not, the same power-heavy profile could make his role—and his value—much harder to sustain.

Photo courtesy of Matt Marton, Imagn Images

Source: AJ Eustace · www.mlbtraderumors.com