Tatsuya Imai’s Astros Future Hinges on Command and a Third Pitch
Tatsuya Imai has the raw ingredients to start for Houston, but his first MLB season exposed two problems that could keep him out of the rotation: walks and a fastball opponents hit hard. The Astros may give him another shot in 2027, though, because their starting depth behind Hunter Brown is thin. That’s a practical opening, not a guarantee. Imai will need to show that his swing-and-miss stuff can survive longer outings without giving hitters free passes or letting them punish his most-used pitch.
A rough first season, with another chance ahead
Imai finished with a 4.93 ERA over 76 2/3 innings, making 23 appearances, including 15 starts. He failed to get through the first inning in three of them, then spent the final two months mostly in the bullpen, appearing just eight times. He made Houston’s postseason roster but didn’t pitch in the Wild Card round. The season’s shape matters: Imai had a chance to establish himself as a starter, but his role narrowed as the year went on. His results left the Astros with a reason to reconsider how they use him.
His 28.7% strikeout rate showed that his stuff can miss bats. His 15.1% walk rate was far harder to overlook. Among pitchers with at least 70 innings, no one walked hitters more often. That gap between strikeouts and walks captures the central question for Imai: he can end plate appearances on his terms, but too many begin with a free pass. For a starter, that makes every mistake more costly because runners can be on base before an opponent puts the ball in play.
Imai can opt out of the three-year, $54 million contract he signed with Houston last winter. Giving up the $18 million due in 2027 seems unlikely. If he stays, the rotation could still be available: beyond Brown, the Astros’ candidates include Hayden Wesneski, Cristian Javier, Ronel Blanco, Peter Lambert, Ethan Pecko, Mike Burrows and Kai-Wei Teng. That group leaves room for Imai to earn another start, though availability alone won’t settle the competition. Houston will need innings from its rotation, and Imai’s case depends on whether he can offer more predictable outings than he did in his first season.

The two-pitch mix needs another answer
Imai relied on his four-seamer and slider nearly 90% of the time. That can work for a starter, as early versions of Spencer Strider and Hunter Greene showed, but the two main pitches need to dominate. Imai’s slider did: it produced a near-40% whiff rate and held hitters to a .167 average. It gives him a clear strength to build around. The harder question is whether the rest of his repertoire can keep hitters from sitting on the fastball or waiting for the slider.
The fastball was less convincing. It averaged 94.8 mph, with low ride and above-average arm-side run. It limited some damage, but hitters batted .280 against it and made hard contact 47% of the time. Its Run Value was zero. Those figures don’t mean the pitch can’t work; they do mean that velocity and movement haven’t translated into consistent results so far. A starter who throws a fastball this often needs it to command respect, especially when the slider is doing most of the work.
Imai has several other pitches on paper. Baseball Savant recorded a sinker, splitter and changeup, each used only 2% to 5% of the time, along with six curveballs. The splitter and changeup were used almost exclusively against left-handers. A more dependable option against them would help: lefties posted a .714 OPS and struck out 27.5% of the time, compared with a .604 OPS and 30.6% strikeout rate for right-handers. The numbers suggest Imai already gets more strikeouts against lefties, but also gives them more productive contact. A third pitch could give him another way to manage those at-bats.
More strikes without more damage
The swing-and-miss foundation is strong. Imai’s 32.7% whiff rate ranked in the 94th percentile, and his 13.1% swinging-strike rate was also a plus. But simply challenging hitters more may not solve the problem: his 44.1% hard-hit rate ranked in the 8th percentile. His overall strike rate was 59.5%, and his walk trouble affected hitters from both sides of the plate. The problem, then, isn’t just a lack of aggression. Imai needs to get ahead while making the pitches in the zone harder to hit.
One possible adjustment is using the sinker more often. The sample was small, but it reached the zone 54.1% of the time, his best rate among pitches with meaningful use. Houston has seen a change like that work: Brown’s breakthrough came after he shifted away from the four-seamer and leaned more on his sinker. That comparison offers a useful example, not a ready-made fix. Imai’s pitches and results are his own, and the sinker’s limited use makes it difficult to know how well it would hold up as a bigger part of his approach.
The bullpen remains a practical fallback
Imai’s relief results offer Houston another route. He posted a 2.00 ERA across 18 innings out of the bullpen, although he still issued 11 walks. That’s a promising result over a small stretch, with the same command concern still present. His two-pitch approach may also play better in shorter outings, where he can lean more heavily on the fastball and slider. It’s an appealing fallback, but it doesn’t erase the question of whether he can limit walks when he’s asked to face a lineup repeatedly.
Houston could use bullpen help. Josh Hader is the closer, while Bryan Abreu is among the remaining options, but Steven Okert and Enyel De Los Santos are also heading toward free agency. Imai could have value in either role, and the roster’s needs may shape how the Astros evaluate his progress. If you’re working in this space, the distinction is familiar: a pitcher’s best pitches can make him useful before his best role is settled.
Here’s the thing: Imai’s strikeout ability makes another starting opportunity reasonable, but the fastball contact and walks make it hard to treat that opportunity as a sure thing. This is more significant than it looks. His next step is clear: improve his command and give left-handers another look, or his best fit may again be in relief. The tools are there. The margin for error isn’t.
Photo courtesy of Erik Williams and Troy Taormina, Imagn Images