Adam Ottavino’s Cat-and-Mouse Matchup With Paul Goldschmidt

| 5 min read

Ottavino’s long game with Goldschmidt

Adam Ottavino faced Paul Goldschmidt 32 times, more than any other hitter in his career. The retired right-hander gave up six hits, three of them home runs, and six walks; he struck Goldschmidt out 13 times. That record looks less like dominance than a running adjustment problem. Across 16 seasons, Goldschmidt has accumulated 905 extra-base hits, a 135 wRC+, and 58.8 WAR — numbers that make a Hall of Fame case arguable, if not settled.

“He was usually the best player on his team,” Ottavino said. His ability to handle right-handed hitters meant he saw plenty of Goldschmidt. Early on, Ottavino leaned heavily on sliders. Goldschmidt adjusted, choosing not to pull the ball; all three of his home runs against Ottavino went the other way. Ottavino responded by moving inside instead of living on the outside corner.

Later, Ottavino added a cutter to the mix, often using it in the middle of counts because Goldschmidt wasn’t expecting it. “It became a lot more cat-and-mouse over time,” he recalled. He never found the matchup comfortable: Goldschmidt arrived with a plan, and sometimes Ottavino stayed ahead of him; sometimes he didn’t.

Most of those 13 strikeouts came when Goldschmidt watched the pitch go by, especially in their later meetings. Ottavino would read a two-strike count as a sign that Goldschmidt was sitting on a slider, then try a backdoor sinker to catch him looking. One strikeout, though, came on a swing. In a high-leverage game in St. Louis, with Ottavino pitching for the Mets and Goldschmidt for the Cardinals, Ottavino went upstairs with a four-seam fastball after showing a sinker in the same lane. Goldschmidt chased it. Ottavino said he was close to giving the game away, so the strikeout mattered.

Another first-pitch four-seamer went badly. Back when Goldschmidt was with Arizona and Ottavino with Colorado, the pitcher tried to steal a strike before bringing out his sinker and slider. Goldschmidt ambushed the pitch for a home run. Ottavino’s read — that Goldschmidt would take — was wrong, and the swing changed the game. Ottavino pitched for five teams from 2010 through 2025.

Random hitter-pitcher matchups

Kevin Cash went 2-for-8 against Matt Garza. Ozzie Timmons was 2-for-2 against Roy Halladay; Chad Mottola, 2-for-3 against Tom Glavine; and Carl Crawford, 2-for-4 against Kyle Snyder. Corey Dickerson went 2-for-7 against David Price.

Ariola’s strikeout breakout

Joe Ariola didn’t make FanGraphs’ 2026 Arizona Diamondbacks Top Prospects list before the season. He could be a much more familiar name by 2027. The 22-year-old left-hander, drafted 213th overall in 2025 out of Wake Forest, began his professional career this summer with a 1.56 ERA and a 45.7% strikeout rate over 34⅔ innings at multiple levels. Among pitchers who threw more than 15 innings, nobody struck out a higher share of hitters.

At the start of the Arizona Fall League season, Ariola said his focus had been simple: fill the zone, get into favorable counts, and let the outs follow. He had a 10.0% walk rate alongside that eye-catching strikeout figure. With the Salt River Rafters, he had six strikeouts in five innings at the time of the conversation. He said he wasn’t chasing strikeouts, even if he liked the result.

His best pitch is a curveball that gets plenty of swings and misses. He also throws a four-seam fastball, a splitter he learned this past season, and a slider. The gap between his professional debut and his college results is striking: in 51 innings at Wake Forest, he had a 5.47 ERA, 42 walks, and 75 strikeouts.

Ariola credited the change in setting. College teams, he said, have to win immediately, while professional baseball can put more emphasis on development because the goal is to win in the majors. The Long Island native said the past year had opened his eyes and helped him improve; his final two regular-season appearances came with Double-A Amarillo. A 45.7% strikeout rate is hard to dismiss. If he keeps missing bats, left-handed relief work could give him a clear path to value.

A home run, a double, a triple — and the singles leader

Over the past 10 seasons, Aaron Judge leads in home runs with 382, Freddie Freeman leads in doubles with 373, and Corbin Carroll leads in triples with 60. Who has the most singles? The answer is Trea Turner, with 1,045. He also has the second-highest hit total.

News notes

Todd Benzinger, a first baseman and outfielder who played for five teams from 1987 to 1995, died earlier this week at 63. He was part of Cincinnati’s 1990 World Series champions, but Boston fans may remember him best for a 10th-inning, three-run walk-off home run during the 1988 “Morgan Magic” run. The Red Sox won 19 of 20 games during that stretch and took the AL East title.

Mike Edwards died September 22 at 74, according to Baseball Player Passings. The Fort Lewis, Washington native played seven games for Pittsburgh in 1977 and 310 for Oakland from 1978 to 1980. He hit .250 in the majors, with 220 hits and two home runs. Fergie Jenkins and Jim Slaton gave up those two homers.

From draft-room doubt to a Cy Young

Peter Gammons’s new book, It’s All About the Players, recounts how Barry Zito ended up with Oakland instead of Texas. The Rangers drafted the left-hander in the third round in 1998, but balked at the $300,000 signing price. Zito returned to college, then went ninth overall to the A’s in 1999.

Gammons recalled a 1998 conversation with a Rangers cross-checker. The scout objected that Zito threw only 90 to 91 mph. Gammons countered that hitters couldn’t handle his fastball, curveball, or changeup, and that Zito led the Cape Cod League in strikeouts and ERA. The scout came back to the velocity.

Four years later, Zito won the AL Cy Young after going 23-5 with a 2.75 ERA. In eight seasons with Oakland, he went 17-5 against Texas — the team that had passed on him.

Foreign affairs

The Kia Tigers and Samsung Tigers are due to play a five-game series for a place against the KT Wiz in the Korea Series; the Wiz earned a bye to the final. Kia reached the series by eliminating the LG Twins. In that matchup, Keisho Shirakawa became the first Japanese pitcher to win a KBO postseason game, according to Jee-ho Yoo of Yonhap News Agency.

Japan’s best-of-seven Japan Series began yesterday. Defending champion Fukuoka SoftBank beat the Yokohama DeNA BayStars 3-1 in 11 innings, with Yudai Shoji doubling home the deciding run.

The Yomiuri Giants hired Hideki Matsui as manager. The 52-year-old former MLB and NPB outfielder starred for the Tokyo club from 1993 to 2002 before joining the New York Yankees.

At Thursday’s NPB draft in Tokyo, the Giants’ first-round pick, Shoki Oda, was a surprise. The highly regarded 18-year-old right-hander had recently said he intended either to sign with an MLB team or play college baseball in the United States. Yuri Karasaw examined the Giants’ decision and other notable picks for World Baseball Network.

Prospect praise, broadcast preferences, and a familiar movie role

A recent feature on Caleb Bonemer left out one exchange from the White Sox prospect’s Arizona Fall League media day. Asked which question he liked best, Bonemer recalled an interview with MLB Pipeline and picked: “Who are the top three hitters in the Fall League that are underrated?” Asked for his choices, he laughed that he had mostly named friends.

A social-media poll asked which World Series broadcast team people preferred: Joe Davis and John Smoltz, or Brian Anderson and Ron Darling. The sample was small, but Anderson and Darling received 89.7% of the votes. That’s a lopsided result, though the poll’s reach limits what it can tell us.

Willie Mueller appeared once for the first Milwaukee Brewers team to reach the postseason. The West Bend, Wisconsin right-hander pitched two relief innings in an 8-2 loss to Baltimore at Memorial Stadium on September 20, 1981. Milwaukee finished the strike-shortened season 63-47, then lost to the New York Yankees in the ALDS.

Mueller’s entire MLB career amounted to six games and 14⅔ innings. He appeared five times for Milwaukee in 1978 and earned a win over Cleveland in his second outing. His big-league debut came at Fenway Park, where he struck out the first batter he faced, Butch Hobson. A decade later, he played “Duke” in Major League. According to his SABR BioProject biography, former Brewers teammate Pete Vuckovich recommended him after the director asked whether he knew someone big, somewhat ugly, and able to throw a ball.

Links you’ll like

Sportsnet Canada’s Ben Nicholson-Smith spoke with Brewers and Rays players about the teams they rooted for as kids and their memories of watching the World Series.

CBS Sports’s Dayn Perry offers a guide to a possible MLB lockout, including the labor negotiations, free agency, and the 2027 season.

At The Athletic, Eno Sarris and Evan Drellich analyze the numbers behind MLB’s competitive balance debate.

The Twins hired Brian Reith as pitching coach earlier this month. Cody Schoemann wrote about Pete Maki’s replacement at Twins Daily.

Adam Sodders traces Baseball-Reference founder Sean Foreman’s path from small-town Iowa to the sports data business for Grinnell.edu.

Random facts and stats

Cincinnati pitchers walked in 26 runs with the bases loaded this season, more than any other club. C. Trent Rosecrans of The Athletic reports that the single-season high is 28, set by the 1999 Seattle Mariners.

CJ Abrams and Miguel Vargas each hit 33 home runs this season. Their run totals and RBI totals crossed: Abrams scored 93 and drove in 106, while Vargas scored 106 and drove in 93.

Bob Uecker started 217 games at catcher in his six-year career. Juan Marichal opposed him in the first of those starts; Bob Gibson was the opposing pitcher in the last.

On this date in 1977, Milwaukee sent Gorman Thomas to Texas as the player to be named later in an August trade for Ed Kirkpatrick. The Brewers bought Thomas back for cash in February 1978. He hit 175 home runs over the next five seasons.

The Twins won the 1987 World Series on this date, beating St. Louis 4-2 in Game 7. Frank Viola went eight innings for the win, and Jeff Reardon retired the side in order in the ninth to earn the save.

On this date in 1973, the Cubs traded Fergie Jenkins to Texas for Bill Madlock and Vic Harris. Jenkins had won at least 20 games for Chicago in six of the previous seven seasons, then went 25-12 in his first year with the Rangers. Madlock won NL batting titles with the Cubs in 1975 and 1976 before they sent him to San Francisco in a five-player deal that also involved Bobby Murcer.

Born on this date, Tony Torcato hit .298 in 43 games for San Francisco from 2002 to 2005. Cleveland picked CC Sabathia 20th overall in 1998, one spot after Torcato went 19th. Eight of Torcato’s 14 major-league hits came against the Los Angeles Dodgers.

Also born on this date, Joe Siddall caught for Montreal, Florida, and Detroit across parts of the 1993-98 seasons. The Windsor, Ontario native is now a Toronto Blue Jays broadcast analyst. His only major-league home run came off Seattle left-hander Jeff Fassero at Tiger Stadium.

More reading

Nick Franklin never became the big-league regular Seattle hoped for after drafting him in the first round in 2009. He played 301 MLB games, mostly with the Mariners and Rays, and finished his playing career in independent baseball in 2022. Now he’s helping prepare the next generation: Detroit hired him last winter as a bench coach for Double-A Erie, and he’s currently working with prospects on the Scottsdale Scorpions in the Arizona Fall League.

Franklin said the opportunity came through Travis Chapman, Detroit’s field coordinator. After the two spoke during the winter meetings, Franklin interviewed with the organization, including director of player development Shane Farrell and infield coordinator Mike Ramazzotti. Detroit was weighing candidates for more than one opening, including a Double-A development coach or a possible fourth coach. The club hired Franklin around January.

He judged his first professional coaching season a success. His work focused mainly on infielders, outfielders, and baserunning. He cited three players who reached the majors that year — Brett Callahan, John Peck, and Andrew Sears — and said he was looking forward to doing the work again.

Source

Source: David Laurila · blogs.fangraphs.com