UCF Stuns No. 2 BYU 39-31 in Double Overtime After Wild Finish
UCF’s 39-31 double-overtime win over No. 2 BYU hinged on a handful of decisions and rulings that could have ended the game several times over. The Knights nearly let a long late drive go scoreless, then appeared to get another chance to win in regulation before a clock ruling sent the teams to overtime. They ultimately secured the upset with a touchdown in the second extra period and a stand at the goal line.
The result gave unranked UCF its first win over an AP Top 5 opponent in program history. It also ended BYU’s time at No. 2 just a week after the Cougars’ memorable, and controversial, victory over Notre Dame. The finish was more than a simple comeback: each team had a chance to settle it, while officiating decisions shaped the final sequence.
UCF passes up a short field goal
With the score tied 24-24 and fewer than two minutes remaining, UCF had a chip-shot field goal available to take a 27-24 lead. Head coach Scott Frost instead kept the offense on the field for fourth down. A successful conversion could have put the Knights ahead; a stop would leave BYU with little room to work with near its own goal line.
BYU made the stop. Quarterback Keyone Jenkins tried to push across on a sneak but was brought down just short of the goal line. The seven-minute drive that had put UCF in position to take the lead yielded no points. Frost’s decision left the Cougars needing to make something happen quickly, but they went three-and-out and punted the ball back.
BYU’s third-down run on 3rd-and-6 was an odd choice with UCF still holding two timeouts. The punt gave the Knights another possession, and the last minutes of regulation quickly became a tangle of replay, penalty enforcement and clock management.
A reviewed fumble and a penalty change the field position
BYU briefly appeared to recover a fumble after Keanu Tanuvasa got to Jenkins near the edge of field-goal range. The play looked like a possible strip-sack in real time, but review showed Jenkins throwing the ball away under pressure. Officials overturned the fumble ruling and called the play an incomplete pass. They did not call intentional grounding.
The sequence still produced a penalty. Tanuvasa was flagged for unsportsmanlike conduct after shoving UCF lineman Brady Wayburn’s helmet back toward the turf at the end of the play. The 15-yard penalty gave UCF field position from which it could attempt a game-winning kick. Had the fumble stood, BYU would have had the ball; instead, the Knights had a chance to finish regulation.
A blocked kick should have brought another attempt
UCF used a spike and a throwaway before Will Stone tried a 46-yard field goal with 11 seconds left. BYU blocked it, but the ball bounced back to Stone. He advanced it several yards before his helmet came off. Officials initially signaled a facemask penalty, which would have given UCF another attempt, then picked up the flag and ruled there had been no infraction.
Even without a penalty, the play appeared to leave UCF with another opportunity. The kick came on third down, and Stone recovered and advanced a kick that had not crossed the line of scrimmage. Under those circumstances, the Knights could have tried again on fourth down.
The officials instead applied a 10-second runoff because Stone’s helmet had come off. With UCF out of timeouts and the game clock nearly expired, that ruling sent the teams to overtime. Rules analyst Terry McAulay later said the runoff should not have been enforced: the helmet coming off was not the sole reason the clock stopped, since the kick itself had ended a legal down. In McAulay’s view, UCF should have received another field-goal attempt, with the clock starting on the snap.
That interpretation added a significant officiating question to an already frantic finish. UCF had reached a position to attempt the kick again, but the game moved to overtime instead.
Both quarterbacks answer in the first overtime
BYU struck first in overtime when quarterback Bear Bachmeier found Legend Glasker on third-and-13. The conversion gave the Cougars a chance to put pressure on UCF, but Jenkins answered immediately. On the Knights’ first play, he threw on the run to Josh Derry for a touchdown, tying the score and forcing a second overtime.
A second-overtime flag gives UCF another set of downs
UCF’s offense stalled at the BYU 8-yard line to open the second overtime, leaving Stone to try a go-ahead field goal. The kick went through, but officials threw a flag for roughing the kicker. BYU’s Kendal Wall bowled over a UCF offensive lineman, and both players fell into Stone as the ball split the uprights. The penalty gave the Knights a first down and a new goal-to-go opportunity.
UCF made the extra chance count. Jenkins threw a touchdown to Grayson Brousseau, a Utah native who had entered the game with one previous catch that season. That reception was also his second touchdown of the year. The Knights then went for two, and Jenkins found Tyren Hornes on a sliding catch to make it 39-31.
UCF stops BYU at the goal line
BYU needed eight points to extend the game into a third overtime, which would have brought a two-point-conversion shootout. Bachmeier scrambled from the 8-yard line to the 4 on first-and-goal. Then the Cougars’ next three pass attempts fell incomplete. On fourth down, his throw to Walker Lyons skipped short, ending the game without another flag or review.
The final 39-31 score only captures the last step in a game that repeatedly turned on small margins: a fourth-down stop, a reviewed fumble, a 15-yard penalty, a blocked kick, a disputed runoff and a roughing-the-kicker call. UCF survived the sequence and finished with the decisive defensive play. For BYU, the loss ends an unbeaten run and its stay among the nation’s top two; for UCF, it marks the program’s first victory over an AP Top 5 team.
The Knights’ win also stands out in a season already marked by a high volume of AP Top 10 upsets. Its lasting feature may be how close regulation came to ending with a different result: according to McAulay, UCF should have had one more chance to win before overtime began.