Jeremiah Smith Leads 2027 NFL Draft No. 1 Pick Odds as Drew Mestemaker Rises

| 5 min read

The 2027 NFL Draft odds have opened a real question: could a wide receiver end the run of quarterbacks at No. 1? Ohio State’s Jeremiah Smith is the favorite at +150, while Oklahoma State quarterback Drew Mestemaker has surged to +250. The odds, listed by FanDuel Sportsbook as of Oct. 29, put Smith and Mestemaker ahead of a field led by CJ Carr at +350.

Quarterbacks have gone first in each of the past four drafts, in eight of the past nine and 10 of the past 12. Smith has a chance to become the first receiver taken No. 1 since Keyshawn Johnson in 1996. His production gives that possibility substance, even this early in the draft cycle.

Smith’s record pace is changing the conversation

Smith has piled up defining performances for Ohio State. Against Iowa, he caught 11 passes for 206 yards and two touchdowns, becoming the Buckeyes’ all-time leader in receptions, receiving yards and receiving touchdowns. Two weeks earlier, he set career highs against Illinois with 12 catches, 217 yards and four touchdowns. That made him the fourth Big Ten receiver since 2000 to reach 200 yards and four touchdown catches in one game, and tied Ohio State’s single-game record for receiving touchdowns.

He also came through in a pivotal moment against Indiana, leaping over two defenders to make a fourth-down catch that shifted the game’s momentum and helped Ohio State secure a road win. Smith has reached at least 150 receiving yards in four of seven games: 151 against Ball State, 164 against Texas, 217 against Illinois and 206 against Iowa. Those four games match the Ohio State single-season mark David Boston set in 1998.

Smith is the only player this season with 200 receiving yards in consecutive games, and just the second in Big Ten history to do it, after Ty Fryfogle in 2020. He’s also one receiving touchdown shy of Braylon Edwards’ Big Ten career record. At +150, the odds reflect both that production and the unusual prospect of a receiver displacing a quarterback at the top of the draft.

Mestemaker’s rapid rise

Mestemaker’s path to the second spot on the board is an unlikely one. At Vandegrift High School in Austin, Texas, he was a backup quarterback who earned all-district recognition as a punter and never started a varsity game under center. Now, seven games into his Oklahoma State season, he has thrown for 2,326 yards and 20 touchdowns. That puts him second in FBS passing yards and fourth in touchdown passes.

His larger body of work has also moved the market. Since the start of 2025, spanning his time at North Texas and Oklahoma State, Mestemaker leads FBS in passing yards. He ranks second in passing touchdowns and yards per attempt, and fourth in passer rating. The result: a rise to +250, just behind Smith in the No. 1 pick odds.

Manning’s odds have cooled

Arch Manning entered the season with a family history that invites top-pick comparisons. His grandfather Archie went second in 1971; his uncles Peyton and Eli were selected first in 1998 and 2004. Arch became Texas’ starting quarterback last season and completed 61.4% of his passes for 3,163 yards, 26 touchdowns and seven interceptions.

This season’s results have been less consistent. Through seven games, Manning has 1,507 passing yards, 12 touchdowns and seven interceptions, with his yardage ranking 59th among FBS quarterbacks. A pick-six and another costly interception helped Oklahoma beat Texas in the Red River Rivalry. Manning has also led Texas to notable wins over Ohio State, Tennessee and Ole Miss, but his uneven play has pushed him from the odds-on favorite to sixth at +1600.

The rest of the board includes CJ Carr at +350, Darian Mensah at +1200, Trinidad Chambliss at +1400, Austin Simmons at +2700 and LaNorris Sellers at +6500. With the season still unfolding, Smith’s record chase and Mestemaker’s rapid ascent have made the position at the top of the 2027 board unusually open.

Source: William Davis · www.foxsports.com