USMNT Nations League Roster Prediction: Pochettino Likely to Recall Veterans
The stakes change the roster. Mauricio Pochettino’s young U.S. men’s national team impressed in its first matches after the 2026 World Cup, beating Mexico, Canada, Chile and Peru in late September and early October. But those games carried no standings consequences. The Concacaf Nations League quarterfinals against Haiti are a two-leg, total-goals series, with a place in March’s final four on the line. My read: Pochettino will call back established players and leave many younger prospects to join U.S. under-20 and under-23 camps in Europe.
Teenagers Julian Hall and Cavan Sullivan have strong cases to stay with the senior team after their recent performances and continued production in MLS. Yet injuries among the available strikers could make Hall’s return especially useful, while Sullivan’s fitness remains a question. The projected squad balances those needs against club form, availability and the pressure of a consequential tie.
Strikers: injuries make room for young options
Projected picks: Folarin Balogun (Monaco), Julian Hall (New York Red Bulls), Justin Ellis (Orlando City SC).
Just missed: Ricardo Pepi*, Haji Wright*, Patrick Agyemang*, Zavier Gozo**, Brian White, Milan Iloski*, Preston Judd.
Balogun is a difficult call on fitness, but a difficult one to leave out. A knee problem has restricted the USA’s breakout World Cup striker to four substitute appearances for Monaco and 74 minutes since the summer. Even so, with Pepi, Wright and Agyemang unavailable, Pochettino may need Balogun in the squad if the Americans are to reach the finals.
That shortage also puts Hall and Ellis in contention. Ideally, both would continue their development with Steve Cherundolo’s squad, but this is a more consequential assignment than the fall exhibitions. Hall’s recent work for the national team and his continued MLS output give him a credible route into the senior attack.
Brian White is the experienced alternative. The 30-year-old Vancouver Whitecaps forward has scored 18 MLS goals, and his physical style could suit a matchup with Haiti. If Balogun’s knee keeps him out, White has a case to fill the gap.
Wingers: club roles strengthen the case for returns
Projected picks: Christian Pulisic (AC Milan), Sergiño Dest (PSV Eindhoven), Gio Reyna (Strasbourg), Cavan Sullivan** (Philadelphia Union).
Just missed: Brenden Aaronson, Mathis Albert**, Cole Campbell**, Diego Luna*, Alex Zendejas, Peyton Miller**.
Dest and Reyna look like safe selections because they’re regulars for their clubs. Pulisic’s status is less certain: assistant coach Jesus Perez watched him come off the bench in AC Milan’s 4-2 loss to Bologna on Wednesday. Pulisic did score his second Italian season goal last weekend, though, and a return to the national team for the first time since the World Cup seems likely.
Sullivan earned another look after a strong September and October camp, but a sore ankle has kept him out of Philadelphia’s last two matches. Whether he plays in Cincinnati on Saturday could clarify his availability. If he can’t go, Leeds United’s Brenden Aaronson is an obvious alternative. Aaronson made his first Premier League start in four games last weekend.
Now healthy, Zendejas is another option. The younger players on the edge of the group may instead join youth camps: Albert has logged just 21 Bundesliga minutes for Borussia Dortmund this season, while Campbell and Miller also look more likely to report to Cherundolo or the under-20s.
Midfield: McKennie returns to a settled core
Projected picks: Tyler Adams (Bournemouth), Weston McKennie (Juventus), Sebastian Berhalter (Middlesbrough), Aidan Morris (Middlesbrough), Yunus Musah (AC Milan), Malik Tillman (Bayer Leverkusen).
Just missed: Johnny Cardoso*, Tanner Tessmann, Adri Mehmeti**, Brooklyn Raines**, Gianluca Busio*.
McKennie’s September omission came after a minor ailment, and his club workload since then makes a recall straightforward. He has started all eight of Juventus’ games in that span and played all but one minute of the last five. Berhalter has also become a regular choice.
Musah’s form at Milan hasn’t been outstanding, but he has started four of the club’s last five matches and played the full game Wednesday, with Perez watching. Cardoso appeared to be in line for a return after ankle surgery cost him a World Cup trip, but a hamstring strain has sidelined the Atlético Madrid midfielder.
That injury could open a spot for Morris. He has been a standout for Middlesbrough, which is leading the Premier League promotion race. Tessmann is starting to find his form for Lyon, but Morris looks well placed to make the squad.
Center backs: Trusty offers a useful left-footed option
Projected picks: Chris Richards (Crystal Palace), Mark McKenzie (Toulouse), Auston Trusty (Celtic), Miles Robinson (Cincinnati).
Just missed: Neil Pierre**, George Campbell, Cameron Carter-Vickers.
Richards remains the defensive anchor after producing his best performance of the season in Crystal Palace’s 1-0 EFL Cup win over Fulham on Wednesday. Trusty, meanwhile, has emerged as the left-footed option following Tim Ream’s retirement. He started three of the four September and October exhibitions and can also cover at left back.
Pochettino used Trusty at left back in the World Cup loss to Türkiye, where he scored, and in the 1-0 win over Canada on Oct. 6. His absence from the November squad, should it happen, would likely have more to do with personal circumstances than performance: he missed Celtic’s last two games after his father, Walt, died.
Fullbacks: experienced cover should return
Projected picks: Antonee “Jedi” Robinson (Fulham), Alex Freeman (Villarreal), Joe Scally (Borussia Mönchengladbach), Tim Weah (Olympique Marseille).
Just missed: Max Arfsten, George Bello, Frankie Westfield**, Luca Bombino**.
Robinson and Freeman look set to start on the left and right. The backups are less certain. Neither Scally nor Weah featured in September, but both are playing regularly for their clubs. Scally has scored three goals, matching his combined total from the previous three seasons, while Marseille captain Weah scored his first of 2026-27 last weekend.
Both are two-time World Cup veterans, and the importance of the Haiti matches favors their return. Arfsten is still adjusting in his first season with Middlesbrough, while Bombino and Westfield appear more likely to join youth national teams.
Goalkeepers: Schwake has a case to start
Projected picks: Matt Turner (New England Revolution), Matt Freese (New York City FC), Chris Brady (Chicago Fire), Brian Schwake (Nashville SC).
Just missed: Diego Kochen**.
Freese was the U.S. No. 1 at the World Cup, but played only 45 minutes across the team’s last four matches and has been outplayed in MLS this season by both Schwake and Turner, the starter at Qatar 2022. Kochen, 20, shut out Mexico earlier this month, though he looks more likely to serve as the under-23 team’s goalkeeper.
Schwake, 25, has the strongest claim to start after an excellent performance against Canada in the Americans’ most recent outing. The final squad will depend on fitness and club commitments, but the larger selection question is already clear: Pochettino has promising teenagers to consider, while the Haiti tie gives him reason to favor proven players who are ready now.