Ohio State’s Top-Five Status Faces a Test Without Julian Sayin
Ohio State can remain a top-five team without Julian Sayin, but its trip to USC will test that case in the most direct way: the Buckeyes need to protect a new starting quarterback against a defense built to exploit uncertainty. The Week 9 matchup at the LA Memorial Coliseum is also a measure of whether Ryan Day can turn his reputation for quarterback development into immediate results.
Protection becomes the central problem
Sayin’s injury follows a Week 7 win over Indiana in which he absorbed four sacks and left with an injured throwing arm. He looked unsettled under pressure, and the Buckeyes’ offensive line again struggled against a strong opponent. Ohio State has allowed nine sacks across its past two games and at least two against each top-25 opponent it has faced this season.
That record gives USC defensive coordinator Gary Patterson a clear place to start. Patterson, a College Football Hall of Famer, can test whether backup Luke Fahey—or former five-star recruit Tavien St. Clair—can recognize and handle pressure in a first road start. A former Power Four head coach put the practical response plainly: “I’m putting in [a] quick-game and running the ball as much as I can to help my QB.”
The challenge isn’t only getting the ball out quickly. Indiana’s pressure disrupted Sayin’s timing and limited the opportunities to find wide receiver Jeremiah Smith. With an inexperienced quarterback under center, USC can make that same task harder through early blitzes and force Ohio State to show it can answer.
Sayin’s absence changes the evaluation
Sayin’s last outing wasn’t a showcase of effortless quarterback play. Indiana hit him repeatedly, sometimes after the throw, and the pressure appeared to affect his composure. Those plays were part of football’s physical demands, but they also exposed how much Ohio State’s passing game depends on both the offensive line and its quarterback responding well when protection breaks down.
Fahey closed out the Indiana win, though his limited action offered little reassurance about what a larger role might look like. Ohio State could turn to St. Clair instead. Either way, the team has to adjust its approach around whoever starts, with the running game and quicker throws helping keep USC’s defense from dictating every snap.
Ohio State has faced a meaningful backup-quarterback test before, and the result was poor. In the 2023 Cotton Bowl loss to Missouri, Devin Brown and Lincoln Kienholz combined to complete 10 of 23 passes for 106 yards. Emeka Egbuka and Carnell Tate were available as targets, but neither quarterback could consistently get them the ball. Day’s frustration was visible that night.
A high-stakes opportunity for Day
USC poses a serious threat, and the stakes extend beyond the matchup itself. The Trojans are fighting for a place in the College Football Playoff, with the first selection committee rankings due soon. Coach Lincoln Riley is also under pressure after a season in which another loss could intensify questions about his job.
For Day, the game offers a chance to show that Ohio State can adapt when its starter is unavailable. The Buckeyes should expect to win, but doing so will require an offensive line that holds up, a rushing attack that can carry weight early and late, and a backup who can make sound decisions under pressure.
That’s the test behind Ohio State’s ranking. A strong showing would support the view that the Buckeyes are a genuine national title contender, not simply a team occupying the No. 2 spot. Without Sayin, the case depends on how quickly the rest of the offense can prove it.