A free-agent forecast built on unusually shaky ground
The biggest takeaway from Ben Clemens’s FanGraphs chat is how little confidence he has in this year’s free-agent projections. He calls this the weakest class he’s covered as a baseball writer, with a contentious new collective bargaining agreement looming. He projects the group to spend less overall than last year’s class, though spending per projected win may be slightly higher. “The macro picture is just really confusing at the moment,” he says.
Clemens is especially unsure about contract length. His estimates lean toward shorter deals, and he admits that predicting whether top players will accept them is the weakest part of his process: he prices contracts of different lengths and judges what seems plausible. That uncertainty matters when the market could shift under a new CBA.
The chat opened with a Brewers fan asking whether the site would publish a managerial report card for Pat Murphy. Clemens said yes, explaining that he skipped both World Series report cards while working on the free-agent list; Jon Becker handled the American League and Dan Szymborski the National League. A joking complaint about Player X being left off the list drew a joking response: Clemens said he hated Player X, then teased the commenter for rating Player Y too low.
Where Clemens disagrees with the market
Kris Bubic is Clemens’s clearest high-side bet. He suspects his contract estimate exceeds what Bubic will actually receive, but says he couldn’t bring himself to project less, based on the information he has and setting health concerns aside. On the low side, he questions whether Randy Arozarena belongs among the market’s top five. He also says he may be low on Matt Boyd, Brandon Woodruff, and Kevin Gausman.
Some placements took more work than others. Clemens says Taira, Sato, and Jeffers were among the hardest to rank. He had trouble forecasting Jazz Chisholm’s contract, but kept him in the top ten, between Suzuki and Arozarena. Taira’s role is hard to pin down, and his style is unusual; Clemens says the player’s age and fastball made him want to rank him higher.
Sato is a tougher call. Clemens says he was too optimistic about last year’s NPB class, but sees some of the same indicators in Sato that he liked in Murakami. ZiPS rates Sato as the second-best player in this class, though Clemens stresses that projections like this carry wide error bars. He disagrees that Sato’s profile is clearly weaker than Murakami’s or Okamoto’s: Steamer and ZiPS both project Sato favorably, in his view. Clemens also believes Murakami was underpaid, and says Murakami’s strong performance in Chicago may be shifting how teams view players coming from that market. He sees Sato as a good player with defensive value and possible room to make more contact, while acknowledging how uncertain that projection is.
A thin top tier, and a lot of judgment calls
Could a lack of top-end choices push teams to overpay the next tier, as happened with Kyle Tucker and Bo Bichette? Clemens thinks that, if it happens, the likely shape is short-term deals with high annual salaries. But he sees that outcome as less likely this year: the class has four or five fewer exciting free agents than last year’s. He expects the middle of the list to draw brisk interest, in part because teams may want to spend before a lockout.
The rankings also came down to close calls. Paul Blackburn missed the top 50 after Emilio Pagán opted out the day before, forcing Clemens to remove someone. He says roughly 20 relievers had similar projections, and Blackburn spent much of the process near the bottom of the list. Clemens had less confidence in the reasons behind Blackburn’s results than he did for some other pitchers.
On Luis Arraez and Gleyber Torres, Clemens rejects the idea that they’re equivalent players for 2027, though his projected contracts—two years and $38 million for Arraez, two years and $28 million for Torres—aren’t far apart. He questions the expectation that Torres will slug more: from 2024–26, Torres had a .378 slugging percentage over 1,700 plate appearances, while Arraez posted .400 over 2,000.
There’s a broader lesson in the chat: even a carefully researched list can be fragile when the player pool is thin and the rules may change. Clemens says he has never been less confident in one of his projections. For readers trying to treat the rankings as a precise forecast, that’s the part to keep in view.
Health questions and unusual arms
The lockout could shorten one player’s career outright: Ben Clemens said that if April baseball disappears and the shutdown drags on, the player he’d been discussing with Meg might simply retire.
Nick Pivetta was another difficult case. A reader wondered why San Diego would decline his two-year, $32 million option when he looked like a solid No. 2 or 3 starter, and whether his medicals explained the decision. Clemens said there was no public information. After discussing Pivetta internally, the staff concluded that the Padres must have serious health concerns if they were willing to turn down the option. Pivetta had been considered closely for the list, but the uncertainty was too great.
Taira presents a different kind of uncertainty. Clemens said he couldn’t tell whether the pitcher’s unusual profile would succeed, and that unpredictability is part of the appeal. He likes unusual arm angles and release points when a pitcher can repeat his mechanics; Taira should be a compelling watch, much like Murakami had been that year.
At 5-foot-8 and 220 pounds, Taira invites comparisons with Bartolo Colon, but Clemens sees a more distinctive mix: high velocity from an exceptionally low release point, with a four-seam fastball as the centerpiece. He also sees a little “Miz” in the profile, despite Miz being enormous: a fastball that holds the approach together, secondary pitches that benefit from its plane and angle, and command that could improve. Eric likes Taira’s splitter, Clemens added, though the fastball will define him.
Contract forecasts under a cloudy CBA
Sonny Gray is a case where annual salary and contract length point in different directions. Clemens would be comfortable paying him $25 million or more for one season, and had Gray tied for the second-highest pitching average annual value in his projections. The harder question is how many years to guarantee. Clemens favored a pay-as-you-go structure, while suspecting Gray wouldn’t want to remain on a long deal if his pitching declined. Gray can still anchor a contender’s rotation and merits a major salary, Clemens argued; he may eventually falter, but hasn’t yet.
The qualifying-offer forecasts were constrained by timing. The schedule meant the projections were assembled before the World Series ended; Clemens said a sweep would have left time to include the list. He also had less confidence than last year about which players would receive qualifying offers. If that list had been known, he likely would have predicted at least one acceptance. Without it, including an acceptance prediction felt premature.
Clemens builds player-by-player projections, then checks them against broader group estimates. He trusts his read on aggregate spending more than his ability to call the quirks of each individual contract, so he uses expectations such as what pitchers will earn overall as a guide. This year has put that method under unusual strain: collective bargaining uncertainty makes the overall market hard to read.
That uncertainty also complicates the question of who might beat expectations in a weak free-agent class. Clemens picked Randy Arozarena as a candidate, especially if a team wants a proven slugger and misses out on Suzuki. He didn’t expect Arozarena to land an unexpectedly rich deal, but scarcity is hard to capture in a projection: Clemens can sense its effect, he said, without being able to quantify it reliably.
Where the fun is
Asked about player-team pairings he’d like to see, Clemens liked Michael Soroka with the Blue Jays. Emilio Pagán pitching in Coors Field could be spectacular, though perhaps for the wrong reasons. He also liked the suggestion of Alec Bohm in Colorado, this time as a compliment, and thought Taira with Milwaukee would be fascinating—even if unlikely.
There won’t be report cards for managers who missed the postseason. Clemens said he wasn’t sure how to produce them, and that much of a manager’s regular-season work is hard to assess from the outside: keeping players prepared, maintaining a shared purpose, and handling the depth chart and pitching staff.
His playoff highlights leaned heavily toward the Brewers and Rays. The Brewers’ run had a personal connection: Clemens’s wife is from Milwaukee, and her mother has season tickets. They went to the games; he didn’t. He also singled out Michael King returning on zero days’ rest and Nick Martinez pitching in the World Series, calling both performances memorable.
The lighter moments mattered, too: the “Bauers/Frelick/Passan bromance,” Pat Murphy needling Cooper Pratt, and Patrick Bailey pinch-hitting for Austin Hedges. Lunch, by comparison, was a Factor meal kit. Clemens said he and his household rotate among meal services depending on the deals and their schedule; they’d been busy, and Factor had a good offer. He hoped the offseason would bring more time—and more interesting lunches.
Projection systems temper the optimism
The biggest signal in Ben Clemens’s free agent outlook is how thin the top of the market looks. More high-end players than usual have signed extensions, and while the middle of his list resembles past versions, its projections are the weakest of any group he’s assessed.
Tarik Taira is a good example of the uncertainty around the remaining options. Clemens expects teams to give him a chance to start, especially if the club that offers the most money sees starter potential. But Taira didn’t start often in NPB, and Clemens thinks his style is better suited to relief over the long run. Even that view comes with wide margins of error.
Casey Mize shows how much a short stretch can distort an evaluation. Clemens had him higher in an early September list based largely on impression, then lowered him after weighing projections during the playoffs. He says he overvalued Mize’s first half and upward trajectory, while giving too little weight to his earlier struggles. The small sample caveat cuts both ways: Mize’s recent success is also based on a limited run, though it’s harder to remember that while he’s pitching well.
Roster choices and payroll questions
Kyle Harrison stayed on Milwaukee’s roster through all three playoff series without appearing. Clemens thinks the Brewers had tested him late in the regular season and weren’t seeing good results, but kept him available in case they ran short on options. Their continued wins and comfortable leads meant they never needed to use him. It was an odd middle ground: preserving the upside without putting it into action.
Questions about Milwaukee’s payroll may also be getting ahead of the facts. Clemens pushes back on the idea that a salary cap and floor are inevitable, and says the final numbers and even the structure remain unknown. Any major change to baseball’s economics would likely need a phase-in period: requiring the Nationals and Marlins to roughly double payroll while the Dodgers cut theirs by two-thirds would be difficult to impose all at once. For the Brewers, that makes a new floor a less immediate reason to bring back Jake Bauers or extend players such as William Contreras, Aaron Ashby, Brice Turang, Mize, or Garrett Mitchell.
And if Randy Arozarena is paid as an established slugger, Clemens sees Philadelphia as a plausible destination. His comparison is Nick Castellanos, updated for a newer version of the player. That’s a useful way to frame the market: familiar spending patterns may persist, even when the available projections offer little certainty about what comes next.