Tarik Skubal Headlines a Thin MLB Free-Agent Class

| 5 min read
Jayne Kamin-Oncea-Imagn Images

This winter’s free-agent class has one clear prize and a thinner supporting cast than any I’ve ranked in six years. That makes the market unusually dependent on two questions: how much teams will pay for Tarik Skubal, and how the looming labor fight will affect the rest of their spending.

FanGraphs’ annual top 50 is back. Dave Cameron, Kiley McDaniel, and Craig Edwards have led this exercise before me; I’m steering it for the sixth time. The work is collaborative, as it should be. FanGraphs staff contributed throughout, and the rankings below pair my market assessments for the top 25 with player reports covering all 50. Those reports come from Davy Andrews (DA), Michael Baumann (MB), Brendan Gawlowski (BG), Jay Jaffe (JJ), David Laurila (DL), Eric Longenhagen (EL), Matt Martell (MM), Kiri Oler (KO), Matthew Roberson (MR), and Dan Szymborski (DS). The two perspectives sometimes overlap, but together they should give you a better read on each player’s career stage, likely free-agent market, and possible seasons ahead.

Meg Rowley was a valuable sounding board. Eric Longenhagen and Brendan Gawlowski helped extensively with my evaluations of international players; Jason Martinez and Jon Becker brought market expertise; Dan Szymborski helped with early projections; and Sean Dolinar provided technical support.

The order reflects how much I like each player, not simply the projected value of his contract. Those rankings often line up, but I may prefer a player expected to earn less than another. I’ll explain those cases in the commentary. Contract figures are estimates of guaranteed money: team options, player opt-outs, vesting options, and incentives aren’t included. Unless stated otherwise, the forecasts are Steamer 2027 projections using FanGraphs Depth Chart playing-time allocations. Ages refer to the season each player is about to play, and every player will have both my forecast and a crowdsourced one.

For the full list of this year’s free agents, including signings as they happen and crowdsourced estimates for players whose future deals FanGraphs polled, see the Free Agent Tracker.

A thin class, with a labor fight looming

There are two forces shaping this market. The first is a striking shortage of top-end talent. Some of that is ordinary chance; free-agent classes don’t arrive with equal amounts of talent. Some is the result of extensions. This spring, Jesús Luzardo, Nico Hoerner, Chris Sale, and Max Muncy signed extensions. Garrett Crochet and Alejandro Kirk would have been available if they hadn’t extended in 2025. A short extension and a 2027 team option took Drew Rasmussen out of the pool, while a vesting option narrowly kept veteran slugger Yandy Díaz off the market. A few different decisions across recent seasons could have left this class with considerably more talent.

The second force is the expected lockout. The league is preparing to lock out players this winter as part of collective-bargaining negotiations. During a lockout, players and teams can’t communicate, so they can’t negotiate contracts or agree to deals. A prolonged dispute could also shorten the 2027 season and cut into team revenue. That outcome may not be likely, but clubs plan around risks as if they could happen. It’s a recipe for caution.

We don’t yet know whether that caution will reduce the money available. Free agents did well during the 2021–22 CBA negotiations, though the timing was odd: many deals happened before the lockout, then the market went quiet for months before another rush ahead of spring training. This negotiation is different. Both sides are proposing changes that could reshape baseball’s economics, so the earlier offseason isn’t a dependable guide.

The league’s proposed hard cap and salary floor could transform the market, and the timetable for any phase-in would affect teams’ 2027 budgets. The union’s proposal would bring less sweeping change, but a soft floor and adjustments to television revenue sharing would still alter clubs’ spending outlooks. Those are only starting proposals; negotiations will change them.

Here’s the practical consequence: I’d be wary of putting too many years on a contract before the new economics are clear. Teams above potential cap lines may need to adapt to new limits. Clubs below a possible floor may have to spend their way into compliance. That could create pressure at both ends. Some frugal teams may need to spend more in later years, while front offices in places like New York and Los Angeles might advise waiting for clarity before committing long term.

There’s a counterargument. The early bird can get the worm, and Tarik Skubal may not be on the market after the lockout. I expect him to be eager to secure a deal before baseball’s economic rules change, and he’s good enough that a team may set aside its concerns and offer a record contract in November. This could be a strange market in which the best player moves early while other teams wait.

One superstar, then a gap

Skubal is the obvious headliner. He returned quickly from an injury scare, made 26 starts, and finished with a 2.72 ERA; several ERA estimators rated him even better. He’s a true ace, the sort of starter who would lead almost any rotation in baseball. Teams seeking a superstar to change their ceiling have one option here. That vacuum behind him should intensify the bidding, and the contract he’s likely to seek has few useful precedents. He stands alone at the top.

There are good players behind him, but no other sure thing. Trevor Rogers, Michael King, and Freddy Peralta can anchor rotations, though none is a capital-A ace. Adrian Morejon has dominated as a reliever and could potentially start. The notable hitters include corner outfielders Seiya Suzuki and Randy Arozarena, both on the wrong side of 30; younger, less predictable Jazz Chisholm Jr.; and NPB standout Teruaki Sato. Sato is younger still, but his power-over-contact approach may not translate cleanly to MLB, and there’s no obvious defensive position for him.

The lack of stars shouldn’t be confused with a lack of useful players. Twenty of my top 50 are starting pitchers, many likely to sign one- or two-year deals at reasonable rates. There are a couple of established closers, some multi-inning left-handed relievers, veteran catchers, three center fielders, and utility players with standout tools. The Brewers found success with lefty relievers Aaron Ashby and DL Hall on their way to a World Series title, a reminder of why that bullpen role may attract buyers. The players ranked 31st through 50th look much like those in a typical year: useful options who generally can’t replace free agency with a lucrative extension. If you’re filling out a roster, this class has answers. If you need two stars to turn a team into a contender, it doesn’t.

How I approached the rankings

There’s extra uncertainty around which KBO and NPB players will come to MLB. That question arises every year, but a lockout makes a move overseas harder to plan. I’ve included Sato, Kaima Taira, and Hiromi Itoh. Other players from those leagues could rank near the back of the top 50 if I knew they were available; I expect they won’t be. For players in that tier, an MLB salary may not outweigh the alternative, especially in a season when changing countries could mean adapting during a shortened spring training, assuming negotiations go well.

I rank left-handed pitchers with strong strikeout stuff above consensus. Over the past two years, the best clubs have stocked up on lefties, and I understand the logic: several teams a contender expects to meet in October have lineups packed with dangerous left-handed hitters. The league is trending left-handed too, as this analysis of left-handed hitters explains.

I’m also more bullish than consensus on the youngest pitchers. With few dependable aces beyond Skubal, I’d rather bet on youth and upside. There aren’t many starters here you’d confidently hand the ball to at the front of a playoff rotation, so I favor the arms with the best chance to develop into that kind of pitcher. Near the bottom of the list, recent performance mattered too: I gave a boost to pitchers who finished the season well. Ranking someone 46th instead of 56th often comes down to preference and tiebreakers. There are reasonable cases for players I left out; these are simply the 50 I like most.

On offense, I’m lower than consensus on center fielders with questions attached: Daulton Varsho, Trent Grisham, and Luis Robert Jr. I have reservations about all three, and minor-league clubs can often supply competent outfield defense. I put more weight on bats that are difficult to replace from within an organization: contact skills like Luis Arraez’s or power like Jake Bauers’s. A general manager should be asking what the farm system can provide and which holes call for a veteran signing.

That’s the broad read on the class. If a player’s placement surprises you, or a position group seems over- or under-represented, those choices follow from the priorities above. I’ll take questions about the rankings at 2 p.m. ET today. With the caveats out of the way, let’s get to the list.

1. Tarik Skubal, SP, Age 30
Contract Estimate
Type Years AAV Total
Ben Clemens 10 $38.0 M $380.0 M
Median Crowdsource 8 $42.0 M $336.0 M
Avg Crowdsource 7.91 $42.4 M $335.8 M
2027 Steamer Projections
IP BB% K% GB% ERA FIP xFIP WAR RA9-WAR
192.0 5.6% 29.4% 43.1% 2.88 2.83 2.93 5.5 5.7

Ben’s Take
Skubal’s market is unusually straightforward to forecast: teams that want an ace want him in particular. There are other pitchers who might deliver an ace-level season, but none offers the same certainty. His market is effectively its own category, separate from the rest of this free-agent class. The question is how far he’ll push past the previous pitcher record, not whether he’ll break it.

Yoshinobu Yamamoto set the previous mark with a 12-year, $325 million contract, which also included player benefits such as opt-outs and a no-trade clause. That’s a useful reference point, though I expect Skubal to favor cash over convenience and establish a higher dollar figure for future pitchers. Ten years is a long commitment for a starter. It also spreads the cost across enough seasons to fit baseball budgets: a model asked to give Skubal a three-year deal values him at $65 million per season, a figure that doesn’t fit how teams generally spend. I expect him to sign before December. His contract is so singular that I don’t expect it to freeze the broader market the way previous blockbuster deals have slowed other signings.

Player Notes
Skubal won back-to-back Cy Young Awards in 2024 and 2025, but Detroit offered him $19 million in arbitration before his walk year. He won the largest arbitration salary in history: $32 million. His season then took an unexpected turn. Loose bodies in his left elbow sent him to surgery. An experimental NanoNeedle Scope 2.0 procedure shortened his recovery to about six weeks, but by then the Tigers’ direction was clear: they traded him to the Dodgers on August 2 for a three-player package. Skubal kept pitching like an ace, but couldn’t deliver a Los Angeles threepeat by himself.

2. Seiya Suzuki: the best bat in a thin market

The gap between Tarik Skubal and Seiya Suzuki is likely to be enormous in guaranteed money. Suzuki could still be the winter’s most valuable hitter. He’s coming off a career-best 4.5 WAR season, with 26 home runs and recognition as a Gold Glove finalist. His five-year major league record is unusually steady: even his lowest wRC+ is 118. Suzuki will be 32, and his right-handed bat comes with corner-outfield defense that may give way to more time at designated hitter. He started 28 games at DH in his walk year. That age and defensive profile make a long contract harder to justify, but his offense has few obvious weak spots. He draws walks, makes contact, and hits for power; if one part of that mix slips, the others can keep him productive. I’d expect the uncertain economics around the next labor deal to make a five-plus-year guarantee difficult, while still leaving room for one of the class’s highest average annual values. Seiya Suzuki, OF, age 32 **Contract estimates** | Source | Years | AAV | Total | |---|---:|---:|---:| | Ben Clemens | 4 | $27.0 M | $108.0 M | | Median crowdsource | 4 | $24.0 M | $96.0 M | | Average crowdsource | 3.79 | $23.7 M | $89.8 M | **2027 Steamer projections** | PA | BB% | K% | AVG | OBP | SLG | wOBA | wRC+ | Off | Def | WAR | |---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:| | 644 | 11.5% | 24.7% | .256 | .346 | .447 | .346 | 120 | 13.6 | -9.3 | 2.7 | The shortage of hitting options is what makes Suzuki’s market so compelling. In a deeper winter, a club with money to spend might choose among very different players—Aaron Judge, Trea Turner, or Willson Contreras. This time, a team seeking a reliable middle-of-the-order bat has far fewer ways to spend. Suzuki is the standout, even with the age and position risks. Since arriving in the U.S. in 2022, he ranks 55th among qualified position players in WAR and 24th in wRC+. The arc matters: after hitting 14 home runs with a .336 on-base percentage as a rookie, he’s kept his bat speed, made more contact in the zone, and raised his walk rate into double digits. After four years of poor defensive numbers, he rated well above average in right field in 2026. That helped push his WAR to a career high. The downside is easy to see. Teams have largely resisted long deals for hitters over 30, and the final years of Suzuki’s contract could be uncomfortable if his defense continues to decline. Still, this is a very good all-around hitter. His strikeouts and double plays are manageable for a right-handed corner bat, and his steady production makes him the best position player available.

3. Trevor Rogers: a young lefty with a real health question

Trevor Rogers has the profile teams look for in a free-agent starter: he’s effective now, has plus stuff and command, and will enter his age-29 season in 2027. By fWAR, he was the second-best pitcher in this class in 2026, and a range of ERA estimators backed up the results. His heavy reliance on four-seam fastballs may also draw interest from clubs that think pitch design could unlock more. The case isn’t risk-free. Rogers has lost roughly two seasons to injuries, and his Baltimore stint began badly. But the pitching problems that once held him back appear to have been addressed. He’s also a left-hander, a useful distinction for teams trying to match up against elite lineups such as the Yankees, Dodgers, and Brewers. Trevor Rogers, SP, age 29 **Contract estimates** | Source | Years | AAV | Total | |---|---:|---:|---:| | Ben Clemens | 4 | $26.0 M | $104.0 M | | Median crowdsource | 5 | $24.0 M | $120.0 M | | Average crowdsource | 4.36 | $23.7 M | $103.3 M | **2027 Steamer projections** | IP | BB% | K% | GB% | ERA | FIP | xFIP | WAR | RA9-WAR | |---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:| | 175.0 | 7.0% | 22.4% | 40.7% | 3.82 | 3.83 | 3.91 | 3.2 | 3.1 | Baltimore acquired Rogers from Miami at the 2024 trade deadline, hoping he could rediscover his 2021 form. He made four poor starts and was sent down, but the underlying idea soon looked right. The following winter, Rogers went to Driveline, rebuilt strength lost after a back injury, adjusted his delivery, and changed his sweeper grip. A dislocated knee delayed his 2025 debut. Once back, he was dominant. His fastball gained more than a tick of velocity, while the stronger physical base helped him locate it with greater precision. The sweeper also emerged as arguably his best pitch. He began getting ahead in counts and placing the fastball where hitters struggled to drive it. Across the past two seasons, Rogers has a 3.20 FIP and 7.3 WAR in 48 starts, each ranking 17th among starters over that span. He threw a career-high 169 2/3 innings in 2026. That’s enough to make him a credible mid-rotation anchor, though his injury record still gives clubs reason to hesitate. In a market with plenty of strong left-handed pitching, a nine-figure contract remains plausible.

4. Michael King: dependable, with some warning signs

Michael King’s projections paint him as a solid starter rather than an ace. That may be the right read, but teams will have to weigh it against his track record and the possibility that he returns to San Diego on a revised version of his old deal. Michael King, SP, age 32 **Contract estimates** | Source | Years | AAV | Total | |---|---:|---:|---:| | Ben Clemens | 4 | $25.0 M | $100.0 M | | Median crowdsource | 4 | $25.0 M | $100.0 M | | Average crowdsource | 3.98 | $25.6 M | $102.0 M | **2027 Steamer projections** | IP | BB% | K% | GB% | ERA | FIP | xFIP | WAR | RA9-WAR | |---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:| | 180.0 | 8.5% | 22.1% | 42.4% | 4.07 | 4.11 | 4.09 | 2.5 | 2.5 | King opted out with two years and $53 million left on his previous contract. His 2026 season brought career highs in starts and innings and 2.6 WAR, a strong rebound after he missed half of 2025. He didn’t match the dominance of 2024, though, and several underlying indicators moved in the wrong direction: his swinging-strike and strikeout rates fell, while his walk rate, xFIP, xERA, and SIERA reached career highs. A low BABIP and high strand rate helped soften those numbers. It’s hard to assume those advantages will repeat. King’s value may instead be his steady presence and flexibility—and the Padres, under A.J. Preller, have shown a willingness to pay a premium to keep their own players. King was a 12th-round pick who found a role in the Yankees’ bullpen before becoming a successful starter. His three years with the Padres produced 7.5 WAR, a 3.15 ERA, and a 3.86 FIP across 432 innings, plus six good postseason appearances. He missed time in 2025 with a shoulder nerve issue and then knee pain, but was healthy in 2026. His strikeout rate has slipped, though opposing contact hasn’t risen in proportion, which leaves some room for the Ks to return. His repertoire is direct: sinkers, four-seamers, and sweepers to everyone, with changeups to lefties and sliders to righties. If a club misses out on Skubal, King should remain a strong option—especially for teams that value a dependable rotation piece.

5. Teruaki Sato: power with a wide range of outcomes

Teruaki Sato offers a classic high-upside, high-variance bet. He has plus-plus power and a swing built to lift the ball, but his strikeout problem is severe enough that clubs will have to price in meaningful failure risk. He could become an impact hitter; he could also struggle to make enough contact to get there. Teruaki Sato, 3B/RF, age 28 **Contract estimates** | Source | Years | AAV | Total | |---|---:|---:|---:| | Ben Clemens | 5 | $22.0 M | $110.0 M | | Median crowdsource | 5 | $20.0 M | $100.0 M | | Average crowdsource | 4.52 | $19.6 M | $88.6 M | **2027 ZiPS projections** | PA | BB% | K% | AVG | OBP | SLG | wOBA | wRC+ | HR | WAR | |---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:| | 607 | 9.2% | 32.1% | .254 | .326 | .471 | .339 | 118 | 25 | 2.9 | Like Munetaka Murakami, Sato is an NPB corner infielder and outfielder whose bat is the draw. His whiff rate in Japan was comparable to Colson Montgomery’s in MLB; Montgomery set the single-season strikeout record. Sato may not carry that level of swing-and-miss into the majors, but the uncertainty is substantial. He’s also below average defensively at both third base and right field. Some clubs may see him as a first baseman; others could rotate him around the corners and live with the glove for the home runs. That makes him a difficult fit for a playoff contender seeking a sure thing. The upside is considerable, though: if the power translates and he holds his own at third, a perennial All-Star outcome is within reach. A rising team willing to bet on that ceiling could find the risk worthwhile, much as the White Sox did with Murakami the previous year. Sato was considered one of the top prospects in the 2020 NPB draft. Four teams named him their first-round nominee, an unusually high number, and Hanshin won the lottery for his rights. The college draftee joined the first team in 2021 and struck out 38% of the time as a rookie. He followed with three steadier seasons, then broke out with major power in 2025. Over the last two seasons, he has averaged 40 home runs and 80 extra-base hits. He won the Central League MVP in 2025 after taking the league’s Triple Crown and is the presumptive favorite to win again in 2026. The power is easy to see. Sato does damage on low pitches, sometimes with a full-body swing and sometimes with strength concentrated in his hands. Most of his slug comes on pulled pitches over the middle or down, especially softer offerings that don’t finish below the zone. His 2026 power indicators support the scouting report: a 56% hard-hit rate, 108 mph EV90, and 116 mph maximum exit velocity. He has the raw power for 30 major league home runs. Power can carry a lot of swing and miss Sato’s contact rate is the clearest warning sign in his profile. He made contact on 67% of swings in 2026, including against fastballs, and missed heaters at the same rate that Cam Schlittler’s fastball missed bats. That’s a steep hurdle for a hitter. Among recent productive third basemen, only Nolan Gorman, Jake Burger and Mark Vientos have produced with contact rates below 70%. Kazuma Okamoto, Ryan McMahon, Max Muncy and Eugenio Suárez sit right at that mark. The broader trend offers some reason for patience: more big leaguers are succeeding below 70%, including recent NPB arrival Munetaka Murakami, whose 60% rate is the lowest in baseball. Sato’s swing-and-miss profile raises his bust risk, but his power gives him a plausible path to production anyway. His defense is shakier. He splits time between third and right field, and his throwing accuracy on the infield is a particular concern. The sensible deployment may depend on where an opponent is least likely to put the ball; a club that trusts his glove at third could choose to keep him there.

6. Freddy Peralta, SP, age 31

Peralta is a test of whether teams trust the track record or the recent decline in strikeouts. The estimates put him around a four-year deal worth roughly $92 million to $96 million: Ben Clemens projects four years and $92 million, the median crowdsourced estimate is four years and $96 million, and the crowd average is 3.96 years at $23.5 million annually, or $92.9 million total. Steamer projects 169 innings in 2027, with an 8.8% walk rate, 22.4% strikeout rate and 37.6% ground-ball rate. Its run estimates are a 4.33 ERA, 4.32 FIP and 4.29 xFIP, with 1.9 WAR and 1.9 RA9-WAR. Those numbers are modest for a pitcher who has often looked like an ace. His 2026 season gives buyers a reason to hesitate: after posting strikeout rates between 28% and 31% over the previous three seasons, he fell to 21.4% with the Mets and 19.7% with the Rays. His playoff run was reassuring on the surface, but came with 10 walks and 16 strikeouts across 21⅓ innings. There’s a tidy story that Tampa Bay fixed Peralta after New York broke him. I’m not convinced the evidence supports such a clean explanation; small samples can make a coaching change look more decisive than it was. Still, the Rays’ adjustments give teams something concrete to evaluate. They encouraged him to feature his changeup more and drop his slider, which allowed a .402 wOBA in 2026 after holding opponents to .197 in 2025, and helped him tweak his delivery. His arm angle rose slightly, his extension increased, and his pitches played up in perceived velocity. The Mets’ defense also did him few favors. New York was just below average overall at -2 FRV, but posted -6 FRV behind Peralta in his 113⅔ innings there; only eight pitchers who threw at least 110 innings faced worse defense. Tampa Bay, by contrast, recorded 7 FRV behind him in 55⅓ innings. His xwOBACON of .339 with the Mets was his lowest since 2022, another sign that his results may have been worse than his underlying contact quality warranted. If you’re a team considering him, expect the fit to matter. Peralta’s tendency to nibble can drive up pitch counts and shorten outings, so clubs comfortable leaning on their bullpens may be the most natural suitors. His declining strikeouts could also push him toward a lower annual salary or fewer guaranteed years. But the Rays stint showed he can still succeed without overpowering every hitter. A large park and strong outfield defense could help him beat his peripherals again. At 31, he’ll face the usual aging risks on a long deal; his 2026 season alone doesn’t establish that his decline has begun.

7. Jazz Chisholm Jr., 2B, age 29

Chisholm’s appeal is easy to see: power and speed from a player who can defend up the middle. His risk is just as visible. Steamer projects 560 plate appearances in 2027, a .234 average, .317 on-base percentage and .408 slugging percentage, with a .318 wOBA and 101 wRC+. It forecasts a 10.2% walk rate, 26.9% strikeout rate, 3.3 runs above average on offense, 3.0 on defense and 2.6 WAR. The contract estimates cluster near four years and $92 million. Ben Clemens and the median crowdsourced projection both land at four years and $23 million annually. The crowd average is 4.14 years at $22.9 million per year, totaling $94.6 million. That price reflects a genuine forecasting problem. Chisholm just had a below-average offensive season, striking out nearly 30% of the time, and his defense can be inconsistent. You can imagine him hitting well and fielding well; banking on both at once is a harder bet. There’s also a less exciting outcome: average offense and average defense at second base, a combination that sounds serviceable but doesn’t tend to command a premium in free agency. Chisholm may prefer to bet on himself with a shorter contract, an opt-out, or fewer guaranteed years supplemented by escalators and incentives. His market looked brighter the previous winter, which adds uncertainty to how aggressively he’ll seek a long-term guarantee. The four-year estimate is a middle ground, but the range of plausible outcomes is wide. His 2025 season explains the optimism. He hit 31 homers and stole 31 bases, produced 4.3 WAR and a 125 wRC+, and posted a .242/.332/.481 line. He then set a public goal of reaching 50 homers and 50 steals in 2026. He did steal 41 bases, but finished with 19 homers and a .231/.312/.399 line, good for a 98 wRC+. The underlying changes help explain the gap. His average swing speed slipped from 73.9 mph to 72.9, he chased more often than in any season since 2021—especially against fastballs and curveballs—and his contact quality fell. His barrel rate dropped from 15% to 8.2%, while his xSLG fell from .481 to .366. Those losses made his rising strikeout rate harder to absorb. His free agency will turn on whether clubs see a temporary slump or a warning that the power-and-speed package is becoming less reliable.
Source: Ben Clemens · blogs.fangraphs.com