Jamie Carragher Warns Newcastle Face a Tough Season After Everton Defeat

| 5 min read

Newcastle’s biggest problem after Monday’s 1-0 defeat to Everton may be the gap between the team supporters expected to see and the one now turning out at St James’ Park. Jamie Carragher called the display flat and boring, and warned that Matthias Jaissle’s side could be in for a difficult season.

Thierno Barry’s second-half goal gave Everton their first Premier League away win of the season. Newcastle were booed at half-time and again at full-time, having managed no shot on target until the 85th minute. The result was their fourth defeat in five matches across all competitions.

Results have outpaced the performances

Newcastle sit 13th after taking three wins from their first nine league games, four points clear of the bottom three. They travel to Fulham on Saturday, a side below them in the table. Carragher said Newcastle’s recent displays, especially at home, had left him concerned about where the season was heading.

“I think it is going to be a tough season for them,” he said on Sky Sports. Carragher felt Monday’s league fixture mattered more to Newcastle than the Carabao Cup meeting with Everton the previous week, while Everton had been especially eager to progress in the cup.

Jaissle, appointed in August to replace Eddie Howe, had offered early signs of promise. Newcastle drew entertaining matches with Liverpool and Bournemouth, with a win at Tottenham between them. That start has given way to a run of uneven results and persistent trouble at home.

No Premier League side has lost more home games in 2026 than Newcastle, who have suffered seven. They have also gone 14 consecutive league matches at St James’ Park without a clean sheet, the longest such stretch in the club’s league history.

A mismatch with Jaissle’s expected style

Carragher’s criticism centred on the contrast between Newcastle’s current play and the aggressive, forward-driving approach associated with Jaissle’s Red Bull background. He said the team had not brought the crowd into the game and described himself as “a little bit flummoxed” by what he had watched.

There had been reasons for optimism earlier in the campaign. Carragher said Jaissle had made a strong impression and pointed to the result at Tottenham. But he added that concerns about the quality of Newcastle’s performances and their underlying numbers had persisted even when results were acceptable.

The 1-0 loss also followed a tactical adjustment from Jaissle, who took a different approach from the teams’ meeting four days earlier. It failed to produce the control he wanted. Newcastle resorted to long balls and second-ball contests, and struggled to create a clear threat.

Jaissle says the team lacked courage

Jaissle said his players had prepared well but could not reproduce their intended style over the full 90 minutes. “If you can’t deliver when it counts, you don’t deserve to win,” he told Sky Sports.

He was particularly frustrated that Newcastle did not use their two holding midfielders effectively in possession, as they had against Everton a few days earlier. Instead, the match became a wide, back-and-forth contest focused on winning loose balls — the pattern Jaissle had hoped to avoid.

The manager also pointed to a loss of confidence across the squad, among younger players and more experienced ones alike. He said the group would have to recover together, while acknowledging that supporters’ boos were understandable and that he was responsible for the performance.

Fulham’s showing against Aston Villa over the weekend gave Carragher further reason to view Saturday’s fixture as a difficult test. With a young manager, a young squad and supporters expecting more, Newcastle need to turn their style and home form around quickly. The next match offers an immediate measure of whether they can respond.

Source: Thomas Smith · www.skysports.com