Brian Carney Presses RFL to Turn Rugby League Recommendations Into a Plan

| 5 min read

England’s men’s and women’s teams both exited the Rugby League World Cup in the group stage. For former Great Britain winger Brian Carney, those results point to a wider problem: the Rugby Football League has identified what needs fixing, but still needs to show how it will do the work.

The RFL has appointed a panel of former England and Great Britain players to discuss the national sides’ future. Carney says that work should lead to action, not another round of diagnosis. In February, the governing body published 144 recommendations covering governance, finances and player pathways. He wants to know how they’ll become a strategic plan.

From recommendations to delivery

“Rugby League doesn't need another discussion about what is wrong,” Carney said. “We know what is wrong. Rugby League needs to demonstrate it is capable of doing something about what we already know.”

He sees a review of the World Cup performances as useful only if it sits within a broader effort to address the sport’s underlying weaknesses. England’s results have sharpened concern that the gap with southern hemisphere teams is growing, but Carney argues that focusing on the national sides alone would miss the cause.

“We're trying to fix a leaky roof by buying more buckets,” he said, pointing to better player pathways, coaching and academies as known priorities. The question, in his view, is whether rugby league has the leadership, funding and resolve to carry them out.

Carney also cautioned against treating a change at the top as a fresh start for the sport’s plans. Ian Nolan, formerly a senior executive at Manchester United, became RFL chief executive in July and has spoken about growing rugby league’s profile and revenue. Carney said Nolan is new to the role and should be able to challenge past decisions, while still turning the existing recommendations into a plan.

“A change of leadership doesn't mean the sport gets to reset the clock every time,” Carney said. “We're very good at strategic reviews, but strategic plans are harder to come by.”

He questioned whether the RFL’s latest statement signalled a new review rather than a delivery timetable. The recommendations had been available for months, he said, and the next step should be clear priorities and a plan to implement them.

NRL talks are only a starting point

The RFL is in talks with the Australian Rugby League Commission, which governs the NRL and NRLW, about possible investment in the English domestic game. Carney said a deal could help Super League grow and raise the profile of both the men’s and women’s competitions, but warned that a new relationship would not fix the sport by itself.

“If we get an agreement with the NRL for them to become a strategic partner in the game, to invest capital, and take management control, that's the easy bit done,” he said. The outcome would depend on how the RFL and Super League clubs use the money and make decisions across the sport.

Carney said stronger competitions and international teams would require significant investment and capable people in leadership roles. Simply linking the English game with the NRL would not automatically improve England, Ireland, Wales, Scotland or France. “The hard work will begin as soon as that contract agreement is signed,” he said.

Widening the player pool

For Carney, better pathways connect grassroots participation to international performance. More people playing gives the sport a wider pool of potential players, while properly resourced academies and coaching can help them progress.

He called on the RFL to make a clear commitment to funding international teams and increasing participation at grassroots level. Without that investment, he said, the recommendations on player development will remain on paper.

The immediate test for the RFL is whether it can turn its published priorities into a funded plan with accountable decisions. The World Cup exits have made the need harder to ignore; progress will depend on what the governing body and clubs do next.

Source: Joseph Davis · www.skysports.com