Florida State Coaching Search: Nine Candidates to Replace Mike Norvell, Ranked

| 5 min read
(Photo by Chris Leduc/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images) | Icon Sportswire via Getty Images

Florida State’s next coaching hire has to answer a question that Mike Norvell’s final seasons left hanging: can the Seminoles build a program that sustains success beyond one exceptional year? Norvell’s 13-1 campaign in 2023 put Florida State near the College Football Playoff, but the committee left the team out after quarterback Jordan Travis suffered a season-ending injury. Two losing seasons followed, and a 36-24 loss to Clemson preceded Norvell’s dismissal.

That history gives the search a particular shape. The strongest candidates bring evidence they can win in the current ACC, recruit and develop a roster, or manage a high-profile program. The more romantic options carry a bigger question about whether their past connection to Florida State can translate into present-day results.

Here are nine names, ranked by how plausible they look as replacements, with the case for each measured against the challenges of the job.

9. Deion Sanders — Head coach, Colorado

The story practically writes itself: Deion Sanders returns to the school where he became a star. His Florida State history is unusually vivid. He excelled in football, baseball and track; in May 1987, he played in two conference tournament baseball games and ran a leg of the 4 x 100 relay on the same day.

That connection would make Sanders an easy name to discuss, but it doesn’t settle the football question. Colorado went 9-4 in 2024, when Sanders coached Heisman Trophy winner Travis Hunter Jr., then fell to 3-9 in 2025. The Buffaloes are on pace for another losing season this year. For a Florida State program looking for dependable progress, the recent record makes this a compelling reunion story and a difficult bet.

8. Jimbo Fisher — Former head coach, FSU/Texas A&M

Jimbo Fisher has the most direct evidence of the group that he can win in Tallahassee. During his previous Florida State tenure, he delivered a national title, five consecutive ten-win seasons and three conference championships. He has also made clear that he wants to coach again.

The complication is that a return would bring old baggage along with those accomplishments. Fisher’s departure from Florida State may have left hard feelings, while his subsequent time at Texas A&M could weigh against him. His history makes him easy to picture in the role; it also makes the questions around a second stint hard to ignore.

7. Zach Kittley — Head coach, FAU

Zach Kittley is the high-upside choice for a Florida State administration willing to make a sharp jump in experience. He took over at Florida Atlantic in 2025, led the Owls to a 4-8 record in his first season, and has the team on course for a winning record and bowl bid in 2026.

His case rests partly on offense. Kittley developed quarterback Bailey Zappe at Houston Baptist, where he was offensive coordinator and quarterbacks coach, and later at Western Kentucky. Zappe set several NCAA records. That background could appeal to a Seminoles team seeking a clearer offensive identity, but Kittley has not yet completed his second season as a head coach. Hiring him would mean trusting potential over a long record of leading a major program.

6. Kenny Dillingham — Head coach, Arizona State

Kenny Dillingham understands Florida State from the inside, having worked there under Norvell, and his stops at Auburn and Oregon broaden his experience. Arizona State’s run to the College Football Playoff in 2024 adds a strong achievement to his résumé.

The question is whether he would want to leave a good position in Tempe for Tallahassee. His connection to Norvell could make the transition feel familiar, but it may also complicate the decision. Dillingham knows what the Florida State job demands; the available facts don’t make it clear that he would be eager to take it.

5. Rhett Lashlee — Head coach, SMU

Rhett Lashlee has built a winning operation at SMU, where the program has backing from trustees and resources at its disposal. His record there stands at 44-17, including 30-6 in conference play. The Mustangs have reached a bowl game every season under his leadership and, at 6-1, are positioned for another postseason appearance in 2026, with a possible second College Football Playoff berth.

From Florida State’s perspective, hiring Lashlee would take a successful coach from an ACC rival. From his perspective, it would mean leaving a stable program for one coming off two losing seasons. SMU is already a strong conference team, so the Seminoles would need to make a persuasive case that the greater profile and challenge of the job outweigh the security he has built.

4. Glenn Schumann — Defensive coordinator, Georgia

Glenn Schumann would represent a notable change in hiring profile. Florida State has generally favored coaches with offensive backgrounds; the last head coach it hired with a purely defensive background was former South Carolina defensive coordinator Larry Jones in 1971.

Schumann’s credentials include time under both Kirby Smart and Nick Saban, and his name has appeared on shortlists in recent coaching cycles. Smart backed him for the North Carolina job in 2024, before the school hired Bill Belichick. Schumann has yet to lead a team as a head coach, so Florida State would be betting that his experience in elite programs can translate into running one of his own. The repeated interest suggests he could be approaching that opportunity.

3. Eliah Drinkwitz — Head coach, Missouri

Eliah Drinkwitz has given Missouri a steady run of competitive seasons in the SEC. The Tigers have reached a bowl game every year of his tenure, won 11 games in 2023 and ten in 2024, and are on pace for another double-digit win total this year.

That consistency makes him a serious candidate, while the question of Missouri’s ceiling could make Florida State attractive. The SEC includes major programs such as LSU and Alabama, and Drinkwitz might see Tallahassee as a chance to take charge of a high-profile program with a direct path to conference contention. Whether he sees the move that way is uncertain, but his results give the Seminoles a credible case to make.

2. Jake Dickert — Head coach, Wake Forest

Jake Dickert’s record makes him one of the clearest fits on paper. Wake Forest finished 9-4 last season and is 7-1 this year, ranked among the nation’s top 15. Dickert also left Washington State with a 23-20 record and has gone 16-5 in two years at Wake Forest.

There’s a practical case beyond the win totals. Dickert works well with Wake Forest general manager Rob Schlaeger, and their approach to finding talent and recruiting players to campus could suit the ACC. Florida State would be hiring someone who has delivered in the conference and shown he can build a team across more than one stop. That combination puts him near the top of the list, though another candidate has the stronger Seminole connection.

1. Manny Diaz — Head coach, Duke

Manny Diaz has the strongest blend of Florida State ties and recent ACC results. He attended the university, earned a communications degree in 1995 and began his coaching career as a graduate assistant under Bobby Bowden. His path since then has included NC State, Texas, Mississippi State, Miami and Penn State, as well as a first head coaching stint with Miami.

His work at Duke is the more persuasive part of the case. Diaz led the Blue Devils to nine-win seasons in both 2024 and 2025, and Duke won the ACC Championship Game last season as a surprise champion. He knows Florida, understands the conference and has already shown he can build a winning team in the league Florida State must navigate.

That makes Diaz the most convincing candidate in this field: not simply a former Seminole returning home, but a coach whose recent results fit the job’s immediate demands. Florida State needs its next leader to turn a promising peak into a stable program. Diaz’s combination of regional familiarity, conference experience and success at Duke gives him the clearest case to do that.

Source: Mark Schofield · www.sbnation.com