Ohio State’s Playoff Hopes Face a Test of Quarterback Depth and Offensive Lineup
Ohio State’s playoff position now hinges on a question that once seemed academic: can the offense function without Julian Sayin? The Buckeyes have dropped a second game, and their remaining schedule offers little room to settle in. They still have a path into the 12-team College Football Playoff, but the combination of an uncertain quarterback situation, a sputtering ground attack and several physical opponents has turned a presumed contender into a team with real work to do.
For a program that has never finished below seventh in the College Football Playoff rankings since their introduction in 2014, this is unfamiliar territory. Ohio State had appeared close to a fixture in the expanded field. Now, a third loss could leave its fate to the selection committee, while a fourth would make the season’s ambitions much harder to salvage. A three-loss team could still get in amid parity across the Big Ten and SEC, but that possibility gives the Buckeyes no assurance.
The setback against USC sharpened the concern. Freshman tight end Mark Bowman turned a reception into a 70-yard gain by hurdling safety Jaylen McClain, a striking play in a game where USC’s offense scored 30 points. The defense has otherwise done enough to keep Ohio State competitive. The larger problem is that the offense has looked fragile even beyond the loss of its starting quarterback.
Ohio State’s backup plan is still a question
Ohio State entered the season with reason to expect second-year quarterback Tavien St. Clair to be ready for a larger role. At 6-foot-5 and 235 pounds, St. Clair arrived as a five-star recruit in 2025 and spent the season behind Sayin. Reports from spring suggested he had earned the backup position and might have a chance to become the next standout in Ryan Day’s quarterback room.
Instead, true freshman Luke Fahey won the job as the first quarterback off the bench. The staff’s choice is all the more notable because St. Clair offers a size and mobility combination that could have been useful in short-yardage situations. Ohio State faced several such opportunities against USC, yet Day did not turn to him. The Buckeyes have not made St. Clair a regular part of the offense through designed packages, either.
Fahey may develop into a capable starter, but his USC performance showed how much growth the offense needs from him now. He completed 10 passes to Jeremiah Smith, who turned those catches into 83 yards, and 11 to all other Buckeye receivers combined. Fahey struggled to threaten USC downfield, missed open targets with several errant throws and failed to create meaningful yardage as a runner. At least two missed passes could have become touchdowns.
The game ended with an especially costly example: Fahey’s attempt at a two-point conversion, with Ohio State trying to preserve its chances, sailed well wide of its target. One play doesn’t define a young quarterback, but the broader performance left the Buckeyes short of the passing attack they need with Sayin unavailable. The timing of Sayin’s return remains uncertain, leaving the team without a clear answer at the sport’s most consequential position.
The run game hasn’t supplied a safety net
Ohio State’s rushing attack was already a concern before the season turned. At the end of September, the Buckeyes ranked 38th in yards per carry when games against Texas were removed from the sample. The expectation was that the early numbers reflected a team still finding its footing. Ohio State had shown a similar late improvement in 2024, when it moved from 3.9 yards per carry in October to 4.4 in November and 4.9 across December and January.
That late surge powered a strong finish. Quinshon Judkins and TreVeyon Henderson became two of the country’s most productive running backs, and the offense finished with 214 rushing yards on 41 carries against Notre Dame in the national championship game. This season has brought no comparable progress so far.
The Buckeyes rank 90th nationally in yards per carry, or 94th if sacks are excluded. The rushing attack has looked effective in only a couple of Big Ten games, against Illinois and Maryland, and has had difficulty against the more imposing fronts of Texas, Indiana and Iowa. USC, despite questions about its defensive front, also contained much of the ground game.
Bo Jackson’s 121 yards on 21 carries against USC were useful production, but they didn’t come with the explosive plays that can change how a defense approaches the next snap. Ohio State has managed only three runs of at least 20 yards since Week 1. Each came in one of the team’s last three games. Among Power 4 teams and Notre Dame, its three such carries against Power 4 opponents tie for 53rd out of 67.
Without explosive runs, the Buckeyes need more receivers to complement Smith. He continues to look exceptional, but the other Ohio State receivers have combined for only 15 catches of at least 20 yards this season, a total that would rank 54th among power-conference teams. Against USC, no other Buckeye caught more than twice. Smith can still win difficult matchups, but opposing defenses have an obvious reason to focus on him when the supporting cast isn’t creating enough downfield danger.
Four opponents can make the remaining schedule uncomfortable
Ohio State doesn’t face another team described here as a great opponent, but it does have four games that could turn into tight, physical contests. That distinction matters for a team whose offense has yet to show it can reliably build a lead or respond when its first option is contained.
- Oregon: The Ducks have had a disastrous season, yet their defense has held five of eight opponents below 4.3 yards per carry when sacks are excluded. Their defensive line includes future NFL talent, and their skill players can challenge any opponent. That combination points to a demanding game, even if Oregon’s record suggests otherwise.
- Northwestern: Chip Kelly is calling plays for a Wildcats offense that has found new life, while the team’s rush defense remains a weakness. If Sayin is still out and the game becomes a shootout, Ohio State may have to prove its backup-led offense can keep pace. It’s a strange matchup to describe that way, but the Buckeyes have given opponents reason to make the comparison.
- Nebraska: The Cornhuskers bring a formidable defensive front, and their home game in Lincoln figures to be loud. Ohio State could find it difficult to establish the run there. The outlook remains uncertain, but this is another opponent equipped to force the Buckeyes into the kind of possession-by-possession contest they have struggled to control.
- Michigan: Michigan has the country’s top defense, while its offense has undermined the season. Ohio State will need to find answers against a unit that makes rushing yards hard to come by. The matchup may also recall 2024, when a Michigan team with a similar defensive profile won in the Horseshoe.
Ohio State should be favored in all four games. That makes each one winnable, not safe. A single defeat could leave the Buckeyes hoping the selection committee sees enough in their résumé; two would end their playoff hopes. The immediate challenge is to restore a credible offense before these defenses get their turn.
At the end of September, Ohio State looked like the country’s most dependable elite team, in part because there was reason to expect early offensive problems to fade. They haven’t. Sayin’s injury exposed the lack of a ready backup, while the run game and secondary receiving options have failed to provide the margin a playoff contender needs. The next few weeks will show whether the Buckeyes can improve quickly enough to make their history relevant again.