Jonathan Taylor Trade: Five Teams That Could Benefit From a Colts Deal

| 5 min read
(Photo by Kevin Sabitus/Getty Images) | Getty Images

Why Taylor could draw interest

Jonathan Taylor would give a contender something that's difficult to assemble during a season: a proven three-down runner who can carry the ball, contribute across an offense, and steady things when the passing game falters. Indianapolis' reported openness to a major reset after its Week 8 loss to Jacksonville puts that possibility in sharper focus. If the Colts are prepared to move a key player, one of the league's top backs could become available at a point when a contender has little time to reshape its roster.

Adam Schefter has reported that the Colts may seek a return comparable to San Francisco's 2022 deal for Christian McCaffrey: second-, third-, fourth- and fifth-round picks sent to Carolina. That's a substantial price for a running back, especially for a buyer that would be giving up several chances to add younger players through the draft. Taylor's ability to shoulder a major role makes the cost easier to understand for a team close to contention, but it doesn't make the decision automatic. A trade would be a bet that his immediate contribution matters more than the depth and flexibility those picks could provide.

Minnesota Vikings

Minnesota's defense would benefit from an offense that can hold the ball and make opponents defend for longer stretches. The Vikings' ground game hasn't consistently provided that support, leaving less room for the defense to recover and for the offense to control the pace. Taylor could give Minnesota a dependable foundation, while also helping the team evaluate its quarterback options in a less exposed setting.

A quarterback upgrade might be the larger long-term need, but acquiring one during the season could be difficult and expensive. Taylor offers a more immediate way to give the offense a defined identity, with a reliable runner who could help keep drives alive when the passing game isn't clicking. That wouldn't settle the quarterback question. It could give Minnesota a clearer view of what the rest of the roster can do while the team considers its options under center in the offseason.

Jacksonville Jaguars

Jacksonville is playing well, with Trevor Lawrence throwing effectively and the defense holding up. A more dependable running game could make that foundation harder to defend and help the Jaguars manage games when they need to protect a lead. Bayshul Tuten has shown promise, though the article describes him as better suited to a rotational role than a three-down workload. Taylor would bring a different kind of responsibility: the ability to handle a central role across an entire game.

The obstacle is obvious. Indianapolis would have to trade Taylor to a division rival, strengthening a team it sees repeatedly and may be competing with directly for the AFC South. That makes the football fit only part of the calculation. If the Colts were willing to make the deal, Taylor could add the chain-moving presence Jacksonville lacks and sharpen its playoff push. But the divisional cost could make this a harder negotiation than the roster need alone suggests.

Denver Broncos

Denver's season will shape the debate around Bo Nix, but the backfield is a need the team can address regardless of how that evaluation unfolds. Taylor could support Sean Payton's offense and give the Broncos a more forceful option when the passing game stalls. That matters for a team trying to judge its quarterback while also giving him situations in which the offense can stay balanced.

J.K. Dobbins has been serviceable, yet the article sees room for a more forceful lead runner. Taylor could take that role while Dobbins provides a change of pace, giving Denver a backfield with clearer responsibilities. Here's the thing: a trade wouldn't answer every question about the offense, and a strong runner can't guarantee that the passing game will become more consistent. Still, Taylor could give Payton another way to keep the offense moving when the preferred approach isn't working.

Seattle Seahawks

Seattle's decision to part ways with Kenneth Walker in the offseason has left the team short of consistency on the ground. That gap stands out more when Sam Darnold isn't matching last season's form, putting added pressure on the defense and Jaxon Smith-Njigba to keep the team competitive. A steadier run game could ease that pressure by giving the offense another dependable source of production.

Taylor could give the Seahawks a reliable option and reduce the load on those two units. For a team aiming to make a deep playoff run, that added support could help prevent the defense and Smith-Njigba from having to carry too much of the burden. And yet, the value depends on whether Seattle sees the backfield as a weakness worth spending significant draft capital to address. If you're working in this space, that's the tradeoff to watch: an immediate boost against the opportunity to add depth in the draft.

New England Patriots

New England has improved enough to look like a possible wild-card contender, though catching Buffalo in the AFC East appears unlikely. The roster has a degree of balance, but the running game remains a clear weakness. Taylor would address that need directly and give the Patriots a more reliable way to sustain drives, which can matter when an offense needs to keep a game close and avoid relying on one route to move the ball.

If they make the postseason, that added dimension could help New England challenge stronger teams by giving the offense another way to respond when its passing attack runs into trouble. The numbers here are underwhelming if a contender expects a back alone to close the gap with an established opponent. Still, improving a clear weakness can make a team more difficult to prepare for. Each potential buyer would have to weigh that lift against the draft capital Indianapolis is said to want.

The cost of an in-season fix

Across these five teams, the appeal is similar: Taylor could fill a recognizable role right away, while giving an offense a more dependable option on the ground. The fit differs, though. Minnesota could use him while sorting through its quarterback plans; Jacksonville would have to account for the divisional stakes; and Denver, Seattle and New England would be weighing a direct backfield upgrade against the value of keeping their picks.

This is more significant than it looks, because the reported price would test how much a contender believes one player can change its season. Similar trades can bring an immediate boost, but a buyer still has to decide whether the roster around that player is ready to make the cost worthwhile (and this is the part most people overlook). Taylor can make a run game more dependable. He can't, on his own, fix a quarterback problem, erase weaknesses elsewhere, or guarantee a playoff result.

A real decision would come down to timing, fit and the Colts' willingness to deal. For a contender with a clear role and a credible path to the postseason, Taylor could be worth a serious call. For a team whose needs run deeper, surrendering several picks could leave too little room to address them. That's the tension behind every name on this list. A promising fit. An expensive bet.

Source: James Dator · www.sbnation.com