Jerry Jones Says Coaching Salaries Don’t Predict NFL Wins. The Evidence Suggests Otherwise
Jerry Jones’s comments on coaching pay reveal more about how he runs the Cowboys than about what wins in the NFL. On a recent appearance on Dallas radio station 105.3 The Fan, the team’s owner and general manager argued that coaching salaries have no connection to winning. His record and the examples of successful coaching hires make that claim hard to accept.
“In the NFL, this is after years of looking at all the teams and all the coaches, there is no — there is zero correlation between how much you pay a coach, or how many coaches you have, as to winning,” Jones said. “There is no correlation. And that’s a random sample of years and all 32 teams involved. So put that in your hopper and smoke it.”
The problem with that reasoning is that a coach’s value isn’t measured by salary alone. But teams that pay for proven leadership have seen immediate results. Andy Reid helped turn Kansas City into a regular contender and the winner of three Super Bowls. Sean Payton has made Denver a contender, putting himself in position to become the first coach to win a Super Bowl with two different teams. John Harbaugh’s arrival has quickly altered the Giants’ outlook.
Dallas prefers the bargain gamble
Jones has described his approach as creative. He told the radio hosts that he has hired coaches with different levels of experience, including people who had never worked in the NFL. He also acknowledged the criticism of his record, while likening the search for a coach to a California gold miner hoping to strike the Comstock Lode.
That’s a bet on potential instead of a premium for a résumé. It can pay off, but it also leaves the Cowboys relying on an unproven hire while other teams pursue coaches whose results are already visible. The article’s argument is that paying more for a proven coach can change a team’s trajectory—and that Jones’s insistence that salary and winning are unrelated helps justify avoiding that expense.
Jones has also said he would write an “embarrassing” check to secure another Super Bowl. The article’s sharp rejoinder is that such a check would likely be small: Jones has resisted firing coaches with buyouts and has not shown a willingness to pay top-of-market money for a new one.
Coaching pay has room to rise
Unlike player salaries, coaching pay isn’t subject to the NFL salary cap. The article recalls that media discussion of this distinction eventually prompted the league to recognize the potential for coaching salaries to climb without a cap. It also reports that some people around the league believe there’s a collective effort to restrain that growth, and that some view Jones as a leading figure in it.
There’s no direct evidence presented here to establish that claim. The economic point is simpler: as the market rises, teams generally face higher costs to attract and retain coaches. Jones may prefer to spend elsewhere, but his choice has consequences for the Cowboys’ ability to compete for established candidates.
One possible target is Mike Tomlin, who could attract offers of more than $30 million a year. Tomlin recently said on Football Night in America that he grew up a Cowboys fan. That connection could appeal to Jones—or, as the article suggests, lead him to believe Tomlin might accept less to coach Dallas.
Buyout costs could shape the 2026 decision
The article ties Jones’s spending habits to the Cowboys’ looming 2026 season. If Brian Schottenheimer has guaranteed money remaining on his contract in 2027, Jones may be unwilling to fire him and pay a buyout. Avoiding that expense could also keep Dallas out of the competition for Tomlin.
For Cowboys fans, the distinction between a coach’s salary and a coach’s cost matters. A team can spend less in the short term by keeping a coach through his contract, but that decision may close off a chance to hire a proven replacement. Jones’s public claim of no connection between pay and winning doesn’t settle the question. His willingness to pay for coaching will help answer it.