10 NFL Players Falling Short of Expectations Through Week 8 of the 2026 Season
|
5 min read
When expectations become the story
The striking part of this midseason list is how many of these players were recently among the best at their jobs. One bad stretch can happen; several former standouts falling off at once raises harder questions about health, fit and whether last season’s performance was sustainable. The 2026 season has had its share of surprises in the other direction. Ventrell Miller and Caleb Williams have emerged, while the Vikings and Raiders have brought an unexpected freshness to the year. But through eight weeks, these 10 players have fallen well short of the form they showed in recent seasons. There’s still time to change that read. So far, though, the results are difficult to dismiss.Quarterbacks under pressure
QB Justin Herbert, Los Angeles Chargers
For six seasons, Herbert looked like an elite quarterback constrained by his schemes. He earned at least a 77.9 PFF overall grade every year, and his turnover-worthy play rate never exceeded 2.6%. His accuracy and decision-making could look almost mechanical. This season has been a sharp break. The 0-7 Chargers expected a major leap from Herbert alongside offensive mastermind Mike McDaniel. Instead, Herbert’s 42.6 PFF passing grade is the lowest among qualified passers, and his 6% turnover-worthy play rate is third-highest. His surroundings have hurt, but he’s also made a steady run of baffling decisions in an offense that hasn’t clicked. It’s too early to write off the 28-year-old. Still, this season puts his future in Los Angeles under real scrutiny, including whether he’ll be there next year.QB Sam Darnold, Seattle Seahawks
Darnold’s revival over the past two seasons looked earned. With two different teams, he turned his talent into consistent production: from 2024 to 2025, his 81.9 PFF passing grade ranked eighth among quarterbacks with at least 500 dropbacks. His 68 big-time throws trailed only Matthew Stafford and Josh Allen. Since winning the Super Bowl in February, though, his play has fallen off. Darnold’s 63.5 passing grade ranks 22nd this season. He has 12 turnover-worthy plays against 11 big-time throws, and his 21.9% uncatchable throw rate is the fourth-highest among qualifiers. His completion percentage over expectation is minus 0.6%, good for 21st. Seattle is 4-4 through Week 8, with a sluggish run game, a new scheme and below-average pass protection all contributing. Darnold is part of the problem, too. If the Seahawks want to reach the postseason, his play in the second half will matter.
Receivers and the price of a bet
WR D.K. Metcalf, Pittsburgh Steelers
Metcalf has always had volatile stretches, but his physical gifts usually kept his production above water. In each of his first seven pro seasons, including his first year in Pittsburgh in 2025, he earned at least a 71.1 PFF overall grade. That floor has vanished. Despite an annual average value of $33 million, Metcalf’s 59.9 overall grade and 60.2 receiving grade are both last among qualified wideouts. He’s dropped 15.4% of catchable targets, the second-highest rate at the position. He also isn’t separating consistently: his 1.20 yards per route run reflects that, as does his failure to convert contested catches. Pittsburgh gave up a second-round pick expecting a difference-maker. So far, the trade looks like a sunk cost, and the Steelers may need to add receiver help before Nov. 10 and again this offseason.Philadelphia’s defensive falloff
CB Cooper DeJean, Philadelphia Eagles
DeJean arrived in 2024 as a second-round pick and quickly became one of the league’s best defensive backs. Across his first two seasons, his 87.1 overall PFF grade ranked second among cornerbacks. He limited catches in coverage and paired splash plays as a run defender with reliable tackling. In 2026, his grade has dropped to 54.6, ranking 101st of 131 qualified defensive backs. Tackling has become a particular problem: his 12 missed tackles are tied for the league lead. He has also allowed a 101.4 passer rating in coverage and three touchdowns, two more than in his entire career before this season. If the slide continues, Philadelphia faces a difficult decision as DeJean becomes eligible for an extension this offseason. He’s also been identified as a possible trade-deadline sleeper for a team looking to reload amid a disastrous season.DL Jalen Carter, Philadelphia Eagles
Carter was a star from the start in Philadelphia. From his 2023 debut through last season, his 89.5 PFF pass-rush grade ranked fifth among qualified interior defensive linemen, while his 13.5% pass-rush win rate ranked 11th. That pressure helped offset weaker run defense. This year, the pass rush hasn’t been nearly as effective. Carter’s 57.1 pass-rush grade ranks 40th among 48 qualified interior defenders, and his 5.9% win rate ranks 44th. Add a 26.1% missed tackle rate and a 58.5 run-defense grade, and the four-year, $152 million extension he signed this offseason looks difficult to justify on current form. Trade rumors have followed him ahead of Nov. 10. Philadelphia is unlikely to give up on the 25-year-old so soon after handing him a record deal, but he shares responsibility for an Eagles defense ranked 29th in pass-rush grade and 28th in EPA per play.Defenders losing ground
CB Jaylon Johnson, Chicago Bears
Johnson was one of football’s top corners in 2023 and 2024. His 1.20 PFF Wins Above Replacement ranked fifth among cornerbacks, and his 90.9 coverage grade ranked third in the league. An injury and individual struggles made 2025 difficult; 2026 has been worse. Johnson’s 32.1 coverage grade is second-lowest among 75 qualified corners. He’s allowed a 71.9% completion rate, 375 yards and 16.3 yards per catch, all bottom-12 figures at the position. Chicago gave him a four-year, $76 million extension in March 2024, expecting to secure a top corner. That contract now looks like a serious burden, and Johnson has become a clear vulnerability on a team with Super Bowl ambitions.EDGE Jared Verse, Cleveland Browns
Verse was among the NFL’s most dominant edge defenders in his first two seasons. His 89.7 overall grade ranked 11th at the position from 2024 to 2025, and his 17% pressure rate tied for fifth. After a summer blockbuster brought him to Cleveland, the production dropped. Verse has a 59.1 pass-rush grade and only 13 pressures on 200 pass-rushing snaps. His 10.4% pass-rush win rate sits in the 46th percentile. The Browns acquired him in the Myles Garrett trade, expecting a young star who could replace a two-time Defensive Player of the Year. So far, Verse hasn’t provided surplus value, much less an equivalent return, as Cleveland rebuilds.CB Kamari Lassiter, Houston Texans
Lassiter stood out even on a Texans defense loaded with talent. From 2024 to 2025, his 87.0 coverage grade ranked seventh among qualified corners, and his 66.2 passer rating against ranked third. Alongside Derek Stingley Jr., he formed one of the league’s best outside cornerback pairings. That performance hasn’t carried into 2026. Lassiter’s coverage grade has fallen to 49.5, 65th among 75 qualified corners. He has allowed 404 yards, second-most at the position, and a 114.8 passer rating when targeted, the 14th-highest mark. Houston sits 24th in both EPA per play and PFF coverage grade. Lassiter’s struggles are part of that decline, and they raise a question about whether he’ll still get the market-resetting extension expected this summer.Running back and line trouble
RB J.K. Dobbins, Denver Broncos
Dobbins played only 341 snaps in his first season with Denver, but made them count. He posted an 80.8 PFF rushing grade, forced 32 missed tackles and recorded 21 explosive runs on 153 attempts. He’s been healthy and played every game this year, yet ranks among the league’s least efficient backs. His 57.8 rushing grade ranks 24th of 26 qualified runners. His 2.43 yards after contact per attempt are the lowest in the group, and his five runs of at least 10 yards are tied for fewest. Denver extended him for two years and $16 million this offseason, a hefty commitment given his injury history. Before the first year of that deal is even over, the team has demoted him in favor of younger backs and may still seek help at the position.