Tigers Add Emilio Pagán on One-Year Deal to Bolster Bullpen

| 5 min read

Detroit’s reported agreement with Emilio Pagán addresses a clear bullpen weakness: the Tigers struggled to miss bats and converted too few late leads. The one-year deal is worth about $11 million, according to Jon Heyman of The New York Post. Pagán declined a $10 million player option with Cincinnati less than two weeks ago, and he’s expected to enter the season as manager A.J. Hinch’s leading closer candidate.

A fit for Detroit’s bullpen priorities

The move came hours after Tigers president of baseball operations Scott Harris said he wanted a right-handed high-leverage reliever who could add strikeouts, as reported by Cody Stavenhagen of The Athletic and Jason Beck of MLB.com. Pagán struck out 25.9% of hitters this season and owns a 28% career strikeout rate.

Detroit ranked 19th in strikeout rate and 21st in whiff rate among bullpens this past season, after sitting near the bottom in those categories in 2025. The trouble showed up in the standings: the Tigers led the American League with 31 blown saves, despite finishing around the middle of the pack in bullpen ERA. Their late-inning options too often failed to hold leads.

Kenley Jansen, who had early difficulty in the closer’s role, was bought out after the season. Will Vest and Kyle Finnegan also had rough campaigns and ended the year on the injured list. Vest had surgery for an elbow stress reaction and on his hip; Harris said he’s throwing again and is expected to be ready for the start of next season. Vest has one arbitration year left and is projected to earn about $4.4 million. Finnegan is under contract for $10.25 million, including an option buyout, making a change harder to arrange.

Pagán’s late-season rebound

Pagán will join his seventh major league team at age 36. He spent the past three seasons in Cincinnati and served as Terry Francona’s closer over the last two. After recording 32 saves the previous year, he went 25-for-28 in save chances this season. A Grade 2 strain in his left hamstring cost him seven weeks, from early May through the end of June.

The injury initially appeared season-ending. Pagán collapsed in pain after a delivery at Wrigley Field and later said he thought his season was over. He’d already allowed a 6.43 ERA across his first 14 innings, so a prolonged absence would have left little room to recover his season.

Instead, Pagán returned in form. Over 28 2/3 innings after coming off the injured list, he posted a 1.88 ERA, struck out 30.5% of batters and walked just 4.5%. He gave up five runs in the second half, all on home runs, and limited opponents to a .189 average and a .230 on-base percentage.

That finish captures both the appeal and the risk. Pagán generally pairs strikeouts with good control and has no major platoon weakness, but he has allowed 1.51 home runs per nine innings in his career. His profile resembles Jansen’s 2026 results, with a better chance of limiting walks. Detroit’s spacious outfield at Fifth Third Park may help contain the cost of Pagán’s fly-ball tendencies.

One year of certainty, more work ahead

Pagán’s market produced a one-year contract instead of the two years and $20 million MLB Trade Rumors had projected, though the reported salary edges past his declined option. Detroit’s estimated cash payroll stood at $149.18 million before the agreement, with a $178.54 million luxury tax figure; both are projected to rise to roughly $160 million and $190 million, respectively. The club could still pursue another late-inning reliever while evaluating its rotation and infield options.

The signing gives Hinch a proven closer candidate and gives Detroit another arm built to generate strikeouts. Pagán’s ability to keep the ball in the park will determine how much that added swing-and-miss helps stabilize the ninth inning.

Source: Anthony Franco · www.mlbtraderumors.com